Deconstructing three-stage overall efficiency into input, output and stability efficiency components with consideration of market power and loan loss provision: An application to Chinese banks

The current study proposes a new three-stage network data envelopment analysis (DEA) model to estimate three different types of efficiencies. More specifically, the input efficiency is estimated in the first stage, followed by the evaluation of stability efficiency in the second stage, and finally, the output efficiency is derived from the final stage. In particular, we consider market power in deposits and market power in loans in the banking production process. Rather than using non-performing loans as an undesirable output, this paper innovatively uses loan loss provisions in bank production. We argue that the loan loss provisions are helpful to improve bank stability because they provide a cushion to absorb unexpected losses, therefore we treat it as a good intermediate output in the second stage and a good intermediate input in the third stage. The results exhibit that the scores of stability inefficiency are the highest, followed by output inefficiency, while Chinese commercial banks have the lowest level of input inefficiency. Not only did we observe that the Chinese banking industry has the highest level of stability inefficiency, but we also noticed that the stability inefficiency had the strongest volatility during 2007-2017. We also explore the impact of non-performing loan ratios from three different geographical areas on bank efficiency in China in a second-phase regression analysis, the results of which show that the input inefficiency results from higher levels of financial risk from the central area in China, while the western area in China has the opposite sign.

Automated summary

The study introduces a new three-stage DEA model to analyze bank efficiency, showcasing that stability efficiency scores highest and Chinese commercial banks exhibit the lowest input efficiency. Financial risk levels are higher in the central region of China, while the western region displays the opposite pattern in terms of input inefficiency.