Primordial gravitational waves from NANOGrav: A broken power-law approach

We revisit the possibility that the stochastic common-spectrum process recently detected by the NANOGrav pulsar timing array experiment could be due to primordial gravitational waves (GWs). A naive extrapolation down to interferometer scales of the blue GW spectrum required to explain NANOGrav consistently with cosmic microwave background (CMB) observations would strongly violate upper limits on the stochastic GW background (SGWB) amplitude from Laser Interferometer Gravitational Wave Observatory/Virgo. In combination with the fact that there are over 19 decades in frequency between CMB and interferometer scales, this motivates us to move beyond the commonly adopted approximation of a pure power-law GW spectrum. We consider a broken power-law parametrization for the SGWB spectrum, which turns from blue to red above the break frequency: while phenomenological, this choice maps to various well-motivated early-Universe models, including scenarios featuring noninstantaneous reheating or a nonstandard background expansion following reheating. After a detailed discussion of the contribution of the resulting SGWB to the early-Universe radiation energy density, we constrain the broken power-law model against a wide variety of multifrequency cosmological and GW observations. We find that this phenomenological model is able to explain the NANOGrav signal while remaining in agreement with upper limits on the tensor-to-scalar ratio on CMB scales, big bang nucleosynthesis constraints on the early-Universe radiation energy density, and upper limits on the SGWB amplitude on interferometer scales. We briefly discuss the very bright prospects for testing this model with next-generation probes across the GW frequency landscape, which motivate further exploring connections to specific well-motivated early-Universe models.

Automated summary

This study revisits the possibility that the stochastic common-spectrum process detected by the NANOGrav pulsar timing array experiment could be due to primordial gravitational waves. By considering a broken power-law parametrization for the stochastic gravitational wave background (SGWB) spectrum, the authors find that this phenomenological model is able to explain the NANOGrav signal while remaining consistent with a variety of cosmological and gravitational wave observations. Further exploration of connections to specific well-motivated early-Universe models is warranted.