Toxicity assessment of carvacrol and its acetylated derivative in early staged zebrafish (Danio rerio): Safer alternatives to fipronil-based pesticides?

Fipronil is a broad-spectrum pesticide presenting high acute toxicity to non-target organisms, particularly to aquatic species. Natural compounds stand out as promising alternatives to the use of synthetic pesticides such as fipronil. Thus, our study aimed to compare the toxicity of carvacrol (natural), acetylcarvacrol (semisynthetic), and fipronil (synthetic) to early staged zebrafish. We conducted a series of toxicity assays at concentrations ranging from 0.01 mu M to 25 mu M for fipronil and 0.01 mu M to 200 mu M for carvacrol and acetylcarvacrol, depending on the assay, after 7-days post-fertilization (dpf). The potency (EC50) of fipronil was similar to 1 mu M for both deformities and mortality at 7 dpf, whereas EC50 was >50 mu M for carvacrol and >70 mu M for acetylcarvacrol. Fipronil at 0.1 and 1 mu M caused a decrease in body length and swim bladder area of larvae at 7dpf, but no difference was observed for either carvacrol or acetylcarvacrol. Based upon the visual motor response test, fipronil induced hypoactivity in larval zebrafish at 1 mu M and acetylcarvacrol induced hyperactivity at 0.1 mu M. Anxiolytic-type behaviors were not affected by any of these chemicals. All chemicals increased the production of reactive oxygen species at 7 dpf, but not at 2 dpf. Genes related to swim bladder inflation, oxidative stress, lipid metabolism, and mitochondrial activity were measured; only fipronil induced upregulation of atp5f1c. There were no changes were observed in oxygen consumption rates of fish and apoptosis. Taken together, our data suggest that carvacrol and its derivative may be safer replacements for fipronil due to their lower acute toxicity.

Automated summary

This study compared the toxicity of carvacrol, acetylcarvacrol, and fipronil to early staged zebrafish. The results showed that carvacrol and its derivative have lower acute toxicity compared to fipronil.