4.4 Article

The role of suspect development practices in eyewitness identification accuracy and racial disparities in wrongful conviction

Related references

Note: Only part of the references are listed.
Article Health Policy & Services

The Rule Out Procedure: A Signal-Detection-Informed Approach to the Collection of Eyewitness Identification Evidence

Andrew M. Smith et al.

Summary: Visual recognition memory has the ability to differentiate between familiar and unfamiliar objects. However, studies on eyewitness lineups suggest that memory is better at detecting the presence of a culprit rather than their absence. The equal-variance signal-detection model predicts that a one-person showup would be more discerning than a six-person lineup, and a large-scale experiment supported this. However, a modified lineup called the rule out procedure, which involved participants assigning confidence ratings to lineup members based on category identification decisions, had better discriminability than both the showup and the standard lineup. The weak confidence-accuracy relation for global rejections of lineups may be due to flawed design, rather than limitations of visual recognition memory.

PSYCHOLOGY PUBLIC POLICY AND LAW (2023)

Article Law

Potential Causes of Racial Disparities in Wrongful Convictions Based on Mistaken Identifications: Own-Race Bias and Differences in Evidence-Based Suspicion

Jacqueline Katzman et al.

Summary: This study examines whether racial disparities in evidence accuracy or own-race bias better explain racial disparities in wrongful convictions based on eyewitness misidentification. The results indicate that while there is a differential accuracy in identifying White and Black individuals, this alone cannot fully account for the racial disparities in wrongful convictions. Instead, the amount of evidence that police have prior to subjecting suspects to the risk of misidentification likely plays a larger role in explaining these disparities.

LAW AND HUMAN BEHAVIOR (2023)

Article Law

Evidence Strength (Insufficiently) Affects Police Officers' Decisions to Place a Suspect in a Lineup

Jacqueline Katzman et al.

Summary: Eyewitness misidentifications are the leading cause of wrongful convictions, and conducting identification procedures in the absence of evidence puts innocent suspects at risk of misidentification. Police officers showed sensitivity to variations in evidentiary connection, but still exhibited base-rate neglect in their decisions about placing suspects in lineups.

LAW AND HUMAN BEHAVIOR (2022)

Article Law

The Reveal Procedure: A Way to Enhance Evidence of Innocence From Police Lineups

Anne S. Yilmaz et al.

Summary: Recent research suggests that high-confidence lineup rejections can provide evidence of guilt, but limited evidence of innocence is available. Additionally, confidence in lineup rejections provides little additional information. This study found that by showing the suspect to the witness after a lineup rejection and asking about their confidence in the suspect's non-perpetrator status, the accuracy and frequency of high-confidence rejections can be increased.

LAW AND HUMAN BEHAVIOR (2022)

Article Psychology, Experimental

The Rule-Out Procedure: Increasing the Potential for Police Investigators to Detect Suspect Innocence From Eyewitness Lineup Procedures

Nydia T. Ayala et al.

Summary: Psychological scientists have developed a novel rule-out procedure to extract more information from eyewitness memory and help police investigators determine if a suspect is innocent. This procedure is better at distinguishing guilty suspects from innocent suspects and increases the potential for demonstrating innocence.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED RESEARCH IN MEMORY AND COGNITION (2022)

Article Psychology, Experimental

Three-level meta-analysis of the other-race bias in facial identification

Jungwon Lee et al.

Summary: The current research conducted a three-level meta-analysis on the other-race bias in facial identification, analyzing a total of 159 journal articles published between 1969 and 2021. The findings revealed a moderate effect of the other-race bias on face identification, with individuals showing higher rates of accurate recognition and discrimination for own-race faces compared to other-race faces. The study also identified participant race and retention interval as stable moderators of the other-race bias.

APPLIED COGNITIVE PSYCHOLOGY (2022)

Article Psychology, Experimental

Changing the Face of Police Lineups: Delivering More Information From Witnesses

Neil Brewer et al.

Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition (2021)

Article Psychology, Experimental

Eyewitness Identification in Its Social Context

Margaret Bull Kovera et al.

Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition (2021)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Optimizing the selection of fillers in police lineups

Melissa F. Colloff et al.

Summary: A police lineup typically includes a photo of a suspect and photos of innocent fillers to prevent the suspect from standing out. Research on the best filler selection method remains inconclusive, but signal detection theory has been shown to provide a useful theoretical framework for understanding eyewitness identification decisions from a police lineup.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA (2021)

Article Health Policy & Services

Juveniles in the Interrogation Room: Defense Attorneys as a Protective Factor

Caitlin N. August et al.

Summary: This study examines the protective role of defense attorneys in the interrogation room with juvenile clients. Findings reveal that defense attorneys are rarely present during interrogations of juvenile clients, leading to frequent waiver of rights. Defense attorneys are aware of the susceptibility of juveniles to interrogation tactics and are skeptical of the protection parents can provide.

PSYCHOLOGY PUBLIC POLICY AND LAW (2021)

Article Law

Cowitness Identification Speed Affects Choices From Target-Absent Photospreads

Amy Bradfield Douglass et al.

LAW AND HUMAN BEHAVIOR (2020)

Article Psychology, Multidisciplinary

Lessons From Pinocchio: Cues to Deception May Be Highly Exaggerated

Timothy J. Luke

PERSPECTIVES ON PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE (2019)

Article Psychology, Experimental

Predicting High Confidence Errors in Eyewitness Memory: The Role of Face Recognition Ability, Decision-Time, and Justifications

Jesse H. Grabman et al.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED RESEARCH IN MEMORY AND COGNITION (2019)

Article Psychology, Applied

Memory Strength and Lineup Presentation Moderate Effects of Administrator Influence on Mistaken Identifications

David M. Zimmerman et al.

JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY-APPLIED (2017)

Article Health Policy & Services

The Case for Double-Blind Lineup Administration

Margaret Bull Kovera et al.

PSYCHOLOGY PUBLIC POLICY AND LAW (2017)

Article Psychology, Multidisciplinary

The Relationship Between Eyewitness Confidence and Identification Accuracy: A New Synthesis

John T. Wixted et al.

PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST (2017)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Estimating the reliability of eyewitness identifications from police lineups

John T. Wixted et al.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA (2016)

Article Criminology & Penology

Coercive Interrogation of Eyewitnesses Can Produce False Accusations

Danielle M. Loney et al.

JOURNAL OF POLICE AND CRIMINAL PSYCHOLOGY (2016)

Article Criminology & Penology

Age differences (or lack thereof) in discriminability for lineups and showups

Kylie N. Key et al.

PSYCHOLOGY CRIME & LAW (2015)

Article Psychology, Multidisciplinary

Initial Eyewitness Confidence Reliably Predicts Eyewitness Identification Accuracy

John T. Wixted et al.

AMERICAN PSYCHOLOGIST (2015)

Article Psychology, Experimental

Effect of retention interval on showup and lineup performance

Stacy A. Wetmore et al.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED RESEARCH IN MEMORY AND COGNITION (2015)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Rate of false conviction of criminal defendants who are sentenced to death

Samuel R. Gross et al.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA (2014)

Article Health Policy & Services

The Eyewitness Post Identification Feedback Effect 15 Years Later: Theoretical and Policy Implications

Nancy K. Steblay et al.

PSYCHOLOGY PUBLIC POLICY AND LAW (2014)

Review Criminology & Penology

Of guns and geese: a meta-analytic review of the 'weapon focus' literature

Jonathan M. Fawcett et al.

PSYCHOLOGY CRIME & LAW (2013)

Article Health Policy & Services

The Effect of Suspect-Filler Similarity on Eyewitness Identification Decisions: A Meta-Analysis

Ryan J. Fitzgerald et al.

PSYCHOLOGY PUBLIC POLICY AND LAW (2013)

Article Psychology, Experimental

Effect of Viewing the Interview and Identification Process on Juror Perceptions of Eyewitness Accuracy

Margaret C. Reardon et al.

APPLIED COGNITIVE PSYCHOLOGY (2011)

Article Psychology, Experimental

Lessons from the origins of eyewitness testimony research in Europe

Siegfried Ludwig Sporer

APPLIED COGNITIVE PSYCHOLOGY (2008)

Article Psychology, Experimental

Recognising faces seen alone or with others: When two heads are worse than one

Ahmed M. Megreya et al.

APPLIED COGNITIVE PSYCHOLOGY (2006)

Article Psychology, Multidisciplinary

Exposure duration: Effects on eyewitness accuracy and confidence

A Memon et al.

BRITISH JOURNAL OF PSYCHOLOGY (2003)

Article Psychology, Experimental

Simultaneous and sequential lineups: Decision processes of accurate and inaccurate eyewitnesses

W Kneller et al.

APPLIED COGNITIVE PSYCHOLOGY (2001)

Article Law

Eyewitness identification in actual criminal cases: An archival analysis

BW Behrman et al.

LAW AND HUMAN BEHAVIOR (2001)