Vertical Slot Fishways: Incremental Knowledge to Define the Best Solution

Simple Summary River barriers fragment longitudinal connectivity and limit the ability of several fish species to complete their life cycle. Vertical slot fishways (VFS) are the best technical fishway solution to enhance connectivity on artificial barriers. To (i) identify the variables affecting fish passage in VSF, and (ii) the best VSF for two freshwater fish species (Luciobarbus bocagei and Squalius pyrenaicus), we collected data from several fishway studies and applied Bayesian Generalized Mixed Models. Results show (i) that the main predictor for fish passage is fish size and (ii) from the tested configurations, the multiple slot fishway with an orifice was, overall, the best-performing fishway configuration for all fish sizes. Fishways, to be holistically effective, need to be designed with requirements for small fish.Abstract River artificial fragmentation is arguably the most imperilling threat for freshwater-dependent fish species. Fish need to be able to freely move along river networks as not only spawning grounds but also refuge and feeding areas may be spatially and temporally separated. This incapacity of free displacement may result in genetic depletion of some populations, density reduction and even community changes, which may in turn affect how meta-community balances are regulated, potentially resulting in functional resilience reduction and ecosystem processes' malfunction. Fishways are the most common and widely used method to improve connectivity for fish species. These structures allow fish to negotiate full barriers, thus reducing their connectivity impairment. Among all technical fishway types, vertical slot fishways (VSF) are considered to be the best solution, as they remain operational even with fluctuating water discharges and allow fish to negotiate each cross-wall at their desired depth. In the present study, we collected both published and original data on fish experiments within VSF, to address two questions, (1) What variables affect fish passage during experimental fishway studies? and (2) What is the best VSF configuration? We used Bayesian Generalized Mixed Models accounting for random effects of non-controlled factors, limiting inherent data dependencies, that may influence the model outcome. Results highlight that fish size, regardless of the species, is a good predictor of fishway negotiation success. Generally, multiple slot fishways with one orifice proved to be the best solution. Future work should be focused on small-sized fish to further improve the design of holistic fishways.

Automated summary

River artificial fragmentation is a major threat to freshwater fish species. Fishways are commonly used to improve connectivity, with vertical slot fishways (VSF) being considered the best solution. In this study, data from fishway studies were analyzed using Bayesian Generalized Mixed Models to identify variables affecting fish passage and determine the best VSF configuration. The results showed that fish size was the main predictor for fish passage, and multiple slot fishways with an orifice performed the best. Further work should focus on improving fishway design for small-sized fish.