4.4 Review

Grounding United States policies and programs in soil carbon science: strengths, limitations, and opportunities

Related references

Note: Only part of the references are listed.
Article Agricultural Economics & Policy

Challenges to voluntary Ag carbon markets

Oranuch Wongpiyabovorn et al.

Summary: This article analyzes the major challenges from both the demand and supply sides to voluntary agricultural carbon credit programs and serves as a resource for researchers, producers, policymakers, and other stakeholders who seek a comprehensive analysis of the challenges faced by this market.

APPLIED ECONOMIC PERSPECTIVES AND POLICY (2023)

Article Soil Science

Valid inferences about soil carbon in heterogeneous landscapes

Paige Stanley et al.

Summary: Using soil organic carbon (SOC) to generate carbon offsets requires accurate quantification of SOC sequestration. However, current measurement protocols often fail to address issues such as spatial heterogeneity, variability of laboratory assays, and inadequate statistical methods, which undermines climate change mitigation efforts. To improve the reliability of SOC offsets, future protocols should include power analyses accounting for spatial heterogeneity, minimize compositing, use dry combustion analysis from the same lab, and employ nonparametric statistical tests and confidence intervals.

GEODERMA (2023)

Review Agronomy

Current controversies on mechanisms controlling soil carbon storage: implications for interactions with practitioners and policy-makers. A review

Delphine Derrien et al.

Summary: There is currently a debate about organic carbon storage in soil and its potential benefits for agriculture and the climate. This article provides a balanced description of conflicting scientific opinions on soil carbon storage and discusses how the scientific community can support decision-making despite the controversy. The article also examines the advantages and limitations of big data management and modeling in linking scientific theories with stakeholder actions.

AGRONOMY FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Financial incentives often fail to reconcile agricultural productivity and pro-conservation behavior

Andrew Reid Bell et al.

Summary: A series of dynamic games built around collective action dilemmas in conservation suggest that payments to encourage conservation often fail to jointly improve agricultural production and environmental outcomes, but are more successful in more educated and gender diverse groups.

COMMUNICATIONS EARTH & ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Kiss the ground (and make a wish): soil science and hollywood

Ronald Amundson

BIOGEOCHEMISTRY (2022)

Review Environmental Sciences

Ensuring planetary survival: the centrality of organic carbon in balancing the multifunctional nature of soils

Peter M. Kopittke et al.

Summary: Healthy soils play a crucial role in planetary survivability, providing not only calories but also other essential functions. However, intensive agriculture is rapidly degrading soils and diminishing their capacity to deliver vital functions, highlighting the need to focus on the multiple functions of soils for long-term human welfare and the survivability of the planet.

CRITICAL REVIEWS IN ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY (2022)

Review Ecology

Deconstructing the microbial necromass continuum to inform soil carbon sequestration

Kate M. Buckeridge et al.

Summary: Looking at the necromass continuum, three conclusions are drawn for future research. Firstly, controls on necromass persistence become clearer when viewed through the continuum's lens; secondly, destabilization is the least understood stage with recycling also insufficiently evidenced in many ecosystems; and thirdly, the response of necromass process rates to climate change remains unresolved for most continuum stages and ecosystems.

FUNCTIONAL ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Perspectives on organic transition from transitioning farmers and farmers who decided not to transition

Garry Stephenson et al.

Summary: The report highlights the gap between the growing demand for organic food and farm products and the insufficient domestic supply in the US. To increase domestic supply, more farms need to transition to certified organic production. Understanding the motivations and obstacles faced by farmers in the transition process is essential for supporting them effectively.

RENEWABLE AGRICULTURE AND FOOD SYSTEMS (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Biogeochemical constraints on climate change mitigation through regenerative farming

William H. Schlesinger

Summary: This review suggests that most of the management practices associated with regenerative agriculture are unlikely to result in significant net sequestration of organic carbon in soils. Certain improved practices, such as increased fertilizer use, manuring, and applications of biochar, face limitations due to biogeochemical stoichiometry and the availability of organic inputs. Other practices, such as fertilizer applications, irrigation, and applications of ground silicate minerals, lead to emissions of carbon dioxide that offset the net sequestration of carbon in soils. Even with best management practices, carbon sequestration in agricultural soils is likely to offer only a small net storage that can be traded as carbon credits.

BIOGEOCHEMISTRY (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Soil science in the time of climate mitigation

Ronald Amundson et al.

Summary: This article discusses the challenges faced by soil carbon management researchers in the face of external pressures such as climate mitigation, carbon markets and political ambitions. It proposes a shift from technical carbon sequestration potentials to socially achievable estimates, and emphasizes the need to prioritize climate-relevant social science and soil feedback research.

BIOGEOCHEMISTRY (2022)

Review Medicine, General & Internal

Climate Change, Fossil-Fuel Pollution, and Children's Health

Frederica Perera et al.

Summary: Climate change and fossil-fuel pollution have detrimental effects on children's health, with a disproportionate impact on children from communities of color and low-income communities.

NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Drivers and trends of global soil microbial carbon over two decades

Guillaume Patoine et al.

Summary: Soil microorganisms play a crucial role in maintaining soil functions and services, but our understanding of their spatial-temporal dynamics is still limited. This study analyzes the temporal trends in soil microbial biomass carbon and identifies the main drivers of change, revealing the areas sensitive to environmental factors. The research finds that global soil microbial biomass carbon has decreased by approximately 3.4% over the past 20 years, with increasing temperatures being the main driver of decline in the northern regions.

NATURE COMMUNICATIONS (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Soil carbon sequestration as a climate strategy: what do farmers think?

Holly Jean Buck et al.

Summary: This article provides a systematic review of the social science literature on farmer adoption of soil carbon sequestration practices and participation in carbon markets or programs. The findings suggest that co-benefits are a strong motivator for adoption, but the literature on the social aspects of scaling soil carbon sequestration is limited.

BIOGEOCHEMISTRY (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Initial soil organic carbon stocks govern changes in soil carbon: Reality or artifact?

Eric W. Slessarev et al.

Summary: Changes in soil organic carbon storage can impact global climate, and identifying environments that can gain or lose SOC is important. However, the observation that SOC-poor soils tend to gain or retain carbon more readily than SOC-rich soils may be influenced by statistical artifacts. Applying statistical corrections and avoiding normalized metrics can address this issue and improve scientific inference for environmental management.

GLOBAL CHANGE BIOLOGY (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

From planetary to regional boundaries for agricultural nitrogen pollution

L. F. Schulte-Uebbing et al.

Summary: Excessive agricultural nitrogen use causes environmental problems globally. Regional boundaries for agricultural nitrogen surplus need to be established, and nitrogen use efficiency should be improved to ensure sustainable food production.

NATURE (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Multiple soil map comparison highlights challenges for predicting topsoil organic carbon concentration at national scale

C. J. Feeney et al.

Summary: Soil organic carbon concentration is an important indicator of soil health and has significant impacts on food production and climate change mitigation. Digital soil mapping can reveal hotspots of SOC storage and areas of potential loss, but there are often disagreements between different mapping results. The disparities are particularly significant in carbon-rich soils. Reducing mapping uncertainties requires addressing statistical limitations and capturing the convergence of physical factors.

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2022)

Article Soil Science

Bypass and hyperbole in soil research: A personal view on plausible causes and possible remedies

Philippe C. Baveye

Summary: The literature related to soils in recent decades often shows instances of bypass and hyperbole, which are detrimental to the long-term pursuit of scientific research. It is important for institutions and individuals in the field to address these issues in order to ensure the integrity and progress of soil research.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF SOIL SCIENCE (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Infrared spectroscopy approaches support soil organic carbon estimations to evaluate land degradation

Bernard G. Barthes et al.

Summary: Traditional determination of soil organic carbon is cumbersome, but diffuse reflectance infrared spectroscopy (DRIS) offers a time- and cost-effective approach for predicting SOC concentration, supporting better evaluation of soil and land degradation.

LAND DEGRADATION & DEVELOPMENT (2021)

Article Environmental Studies

Caught in between: credibility and feasibility of the voluntary carbon market post-2020

Nicolas Kreibich et al.

Summary: Many companies have pledged to achieve net zero emissions, but the supply side of the voluntary carbon market is struggling to align with the legal framework of the Paris Agreement. There is a growing mismatch between the reliance of private sector on carbon credits and the quest for a common position among the main suppliers of the voluntary carbon market.

CLIMATE POLICY (2021)

Review Biodiversity Conservation

Getting the message right on nature-based solutions to climate change

Nathalie Seddon et al.

Summary: Nature-based solutions (NbS) have gained popularity as an integrated approach to address climate change and biodiversity loss, but concerns have been raised about the overemphasis on tree planting for carbon sequestration. NbS should encompass a wide range of ecosystems, engage local communities, and be explicitly designed to benefit biodiversity in order to effectively tackle urgent challenges.

GLOBAL CHANGE BIOLOGY (2021)

Article Soil Science

The 'soil health' metaphor: Illuminating or illusory?

H. Henry Janzen et al.

Summary: The concept of "soil health" as a metaphor is discussed in this article, emphasizing the importance of understanding soil in the context of its ecosystem. The authors propose that the metaphor should be used to generate understanding of relational mechanisms and lead to better management practices, rather than simply assigning a numerical value to soil quality. The continuing usefulness of the soil health metaphor depends on its ability to inspire greater reverence for soil and improve our understanding of its beneficial processes.

SOIL BIOLOGY & BIOCHEMISTRY (2021)

Editorial Material Soil Science

Soil health at a crossroad

Philippe C. Baveye

SOIL USE AND MANAGEMENT (2021)

Review Soil Science

Plant- or microbial-derived? A review on the molecular composition of stabilized soil organic matter

Gerrit Angst et al.

Summary: This study synthesized data on the contribution of plant- and microbial-derived compounds to stabilized SOM, indicating different proportions of contribution between plant and microbial compounds in different ecosystems. Plant biomolecules were found to play a significant role in stabilizing organic matter.

SOIL BIOLOGY & BIOCHEMISTRY (2021)

Editorial Material Soil Science

Is 'soil health' meaningful as a scientific concept or as terminology?

David S. Powlson

SOIL USE AND MANAGEMENT (2021)

Editorial Material Education & Educational Research

On-farm demonstration: enabling peer-to-peer learning

Lee-Ann Sutherland et al.

JOURNAL OF AGRICULTURAL EDUCATION & EXTENSION (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Don't throw efficiency out with the bathwater: A reply to Jeffery and Verheijen (2020)

Bartosz Bartkowski

Summary: The response critically discusses the emphasis on soil functions over soil health concept in agri-environmental policy, as well as the advantages and disadvantages of result-based and action-based payments. It proposes a hybrid model-based scheme as an alternative approach that addresses the limitations of existing proposals.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2021)

Article Ecology

Soil health conceptualization differs across key stakeholder groups in the Midwest

J. Wade et al.

JOURNAL OF SOIL AND WATER CONSERVATION (2021)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Potential CO2 removal from enhanced weathering by ecosystem responses to powdered rock

Daniel S. Goll et al.

Summary: Simulations suggest that vegetation's enhanced CO2 uptake from powdered rock can be a feasible option in mitigating climate change, with enhanced weathering being a potential negative emission technology. Amending soil with powdered basalt may effectively enhance ecosystem carbon storage, but scaling up and addressing potential side effects are necessary.

NATURE GEOSCIENCE (2021)

Article Plant Sciences

Crops for Carbon Farming

Christer Jansson et al.

Summary: The proposal advocates for the design of crop ideotypes with dual functionality, promoting soil carbon contribution and improving belowground ecology, through enhancing root strength, balancing carbon allocation, and designing soil microbial consortia.

FRONTIERS IN PLANT SCIENCE (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Regenerative farming and human wellbeing: Are subjective wellbeing measures useful indicators for sustainable farming systems?

Kimberly Brown et al.

Summary: The text argues for the inclusion of measures examining the health and wellbeing of farm managers in sustainable agriculture indicators, as good farmer wellbeing may indicate a level of functioning across all components of the farm system. However, few indicator frameworks currently measure farmer wellbeing, mainly due to a lack of exploration of the linkages between farming systems and wellbeing. The text explores the utility of subjective wellbeing measures for inclusion in agricultural sustainability indicator frameworks, using regenerative agriculture as a case example.

ENVIRONMENTAL AND SUSTAINABILITY INDICATORS (2021)

Article Environmental Studies

Payments by modelled results: A novel design for agri-environmental schemes

Bartosz Bartkowski et al.

Summary: This paper proposes an alternative design for agricultural environmental subsidies called PAMR, which models results instead of measuring them, to overcome the practical disadvantages of result-based payments. PAMR combines most of the advantages of result-based and action-based schemes, and has the potential to address trade-offs among multiple policy objectives.

LAND USE POLICY (2021)

Article Food Science & Technology

Food systems are responsible for a third of global anthropogenic GHG emissions

M. Crippa et al.

Summary: Data on GHG emissions from the global food system are often scattered and unavailable, but EDGAR-FOOD provides a consistent database from 1990 to 2015. The largest contributions to food-system emissions come from agriculture and supply chain activities, representing 34% of total global GHG emissions.

NATURE FOOD (2021)

Article Agricultural Economics & Policy

Changes in Agricultural Extension and Implications for Farmer Adoption of New Practices

George W. Norton et al.

APPLIED ECONOMIC PERSPECTIVES AND POLICY (2020)

Article Ecology

Multiple elements of soil biodiversity drive ecosystem functions across biomes

Manuel Delgado-Baquerizo et al.

NATURE ECOLOGY & EVOLUTION (2020)

Article Agronomy

Introducing the North American project to evaluate soil health measurements

Charlotte E. Norris et al.

AGRONOMY JOURNAL (2020)

Article Soil Science

A meta-analysis of global cropland soil carbon changes due to cover cropping

Jinshi Jian et al.

SOIL BIOLOGY & BIOCHEMISTRY (2020)

Article Soil Science

Effect of tillage and crop management on runoff, soil erosion and organic carbon loss

Maciej Chowaniak et al.

SOIL USE AND MANAGEMENT (2020)

Article Environmental Sciences

A new soil health policy paradigm: Pay for practice not performance

S. Jeffery et al.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2020)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

A scoping review on incentives for adoption of sustainable agricultural practices and their outcomes

Valeria Pineiro et al.

NATURE SUSTAINABILITY (2020)

Article Soil Science

The policy challenges to managing global soil resources

Ronald Amundson

GEODERMA (2020)

Review Ecology

Reviews and syntheses: The mechanisms underlying carbon storage in soil

Isabelle Basile-Doelsch et al.

BIOGEOSCIENCES (2020)

Review Environmental Sciences

Dynamic Stability of Soil Carbon: Reassessing the Permanence of Soil Carbon Sequestration

Katherine A. Dynarski et al.

FRONTIERS IN ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE (2020)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

The role of soil carbon in natural climate solutions

D. A. Bossio et al.

NATURE SUSTAINABILITY (2020)

Article Environmental Sciences

The concept and future prospects of soil health

Johannes Lehmann et al.

NATURE REVIEWS EARTH & ENVIRONMENT (2020)

Article Soil Science

Increasing organic stocks in agricultural soils: Knowledge gaps and potential innovations

Claire Chenu et al.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2019)

Article Food Science & Technology

The impact of organic certification and country of origin on consumer food choice in developed and emerging economies

John Thogersen et al.

FOOD QUALITY AND PREFERENCE (2019)

Article Soil Science

Digital mapping of soil carbon fractions with machine learning

Hamza Keskin et al.

GEODERMA (2019)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Responses of soil carbon sequestration to climate-smart agriculture practices: A meta-analysis

Xiongxiong Bai et al.

GLOBAL CHANGE BIOLOGY (2019)

Article Environmental Sciences

Estimating the contribution of crop residues to soil organic carbon conservation

Tommaso Stella et al.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2019)

Article Soil Science

A New Index for Remote Sensing of Soil Organic Carbon Based Solely on Visible Wavelengths

Evan A. Thaler et al.

SOIL SCIENCE SOCIETY OF AMERICA JOURNAL (2019)

Review Agronomy

Rewarding Best Pest Management Practices via Reduced Crop Insurance Premiums

Hugh J. Beckie et al.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF AGRONOMY (2019)

Review Agricultural Economics & Policy

Review: The economics of soil health

Andrew W. Stevens

FOOD POLICY (2018)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Multimodel ensembles improve predictions of crop-environment-management interactions

Daniel Wallach et al.

GLOBAL CHANGE BIOLOGY (2018)

Letter Multidisciplinary Sciences

Predicting soil carbon loss with warming

Natasja van Gestel et al.

NATURE (2018)

Article Ecology

Farmers show complex and contrasting perceptions on ecosystem services and their management

Heitor Mancini Teixeira et al.

ECOSYSTEM SERVICES (2018)

Article Environmental Sciences

Multiple models and experiments underscore large uncertainty in soil carbon dynamics

Benjamin N. Sulman et al.

BIOGEOCHEMISTRY (2018)

Article Soil Science

Soil Carbon Loss by Wind Erosion of Summer Fallow Fields in Washington's Dryland Wheat Region

Brenton S. Sharratt et al.

SOIL SCIENCE SOCIETY OF AMERICA JOURNAL (2018)

Article Ecology

On-farm soil health evaluations: Challenges and opportunities

Douglas L. Karlen et al.

JOURNAL OF SOIL AND WATER CONSERVATION (2017)

Review Plant Sciences

Disease Suppressive Soils: New Insights from the Soil Microbiome

Daniel Schlatter et al.

PHYTOPATHOLOGY (2017)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Soil carbon debt of 12,000 years of human land use

Jonathan Sanderman et al.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA (2017)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Decision support tools for agriculture: Towards effective design and delivery

David C. Rose et al.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2016)

Editorial Material Environmental Sciences

Consensus on consensus: a synthesis of consensus estimates on human-caused global warming

John Cook et al.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2016)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Quantifying global soil carbon losses in response to warming

T. W. Crowther et al.

NATURE (2016)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Temperature response of soil respiration largely unaltered with experimental warming

Joanna C. Carey et al.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA (2016)

Review Environmental Sciences

Modeling Soil Processes: Review, Key Challenges, and New Perspectives

H. Vereecken et al.

VADOSE ZONE JOURNAL (2016)

Review Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Factors influencing farmer adoption of soil health practices in the United States: a narrative review

Liz Carlisle

AGROECOLOGY AND SUSTAINABLE FOOD SYSTEMS (2016)

Article Environmental Sciences

Farmers and Climate Change: A Cross-National Comparison of Beliefs and Risk Perceptions in High-Income Countries

Linda S. Prokopy et al.

ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2015)

Article Agronomy

When does no-till yield more? A global meta-analysis

Cameron M. Pittelkow et al.

FIELD CROPS RESEARCH (2015)

Article Geology

Sequestration of inorganic carbon in soil and groundwater

H. Curtis Monger et al.

GEOLOGY (2015)

Article Environmental Sciences

Carbon prices and incentives for technological development

Tommy Lundgren et al.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2015)

Article Economics

Federal Crop Insurance and the Disincentive to Adapt to Extreme Heat

Francis Annan et al.

AMERICAN ECONOMIC REVIEW (2015)

Review Plant Sciences

Sustainable intensification in agricultural systems

Jules Pretty et al.

ANNALS OF BOTANY (2014)

Article Soil Science

Seasonal Variation in Soil Organic Carbon

Stewart Wuest

SOIL SCIENCE SOCIETY OF AMERICA JOURNAL (2014)

Article Environmental Sciences

Global soil carbon: understanding and managing the largest terrestrial carbon pool

Joern P. W. Scharlemann et al.

CARBON MANAGEMENT (2014)

Article Ecology

Soil organic carbon: The value to soil properties

Humberto Blanco-Canqui et al.

JOURNAL OF SOIL AND WATER CONSERVATION (2013)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

No-till management impacts on crop productivity, carbon input and soil carbon sequestration

Stephen M. Ogle et al.

AGRICULTURE ECOSYSTEMS & ENVIRONMENT (2012)

Article Environmental Sciences

SOM genesis: microbial biomass as a significant source

Anja Miltner et al.

BIOGEOCHEMISTRY (2012)

Article Agronomy

Role of Soil Organic Matter in Maintaining Sustainability of Cropping Systems

N. K. Fageria

COMMUNICATIONS IN SOIL SCIENCE AND PLANT ANALYSIS (2012)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Can no-tillage stimulate carbon sequestration in agricultural soils? A meta-analysis of paired experiments

Zhongkui Luo et al.

AGRICULTURE ECOSYSTEMS & ENVIRONMENT (2010)

Article Plant Sciences

Scaling up: the essence of effective agricultural research

J. B. Passioura

FUNCTIONAL PLANT BIOLOGY (2010)

Article Environmental Sciences

Dissolved Organic Carbon Losses from Tile Drained Agroecosystems

Matthew D. Ruark et al.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY (2009)

Article Business

Emissions trading of global and local pollutants, pollution havens and free riding

Emilson C. D. Silva et al.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL ECONOMICS AND MANAGEMENT (2009)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Carbon Dioxide Sequestration: A Solution to a Global Problem

Eric H. Oelkers et al.

ELEMENTS (2008)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

No-till: The quiet revolution

David R. Huggins et al.

SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN (2008)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Historical advances in the study of global terrestrial soil organic carbon sequestration

C. Feller et al.

WASTE MANAGEMENT (2008)

Article Soil Science

Soil carbon saturation: Linking concept and measurable carbon pools

Catherine E. Stewart et al.

SOIL SCIENCE SOCIETY OF AMERICA JOURNAL (2008)

Article Soil Science

The soil carbon dilemma: Shall we hoard it or use it?

HH Janzen

SOIL BIOLOGY & BIOCHEMISTRY (2006)

Review Biodiversity Conservation

Soil carbon stocks and land use change: a meta analysis

LB Guo et al.

GLOBAL CHANGE BIOLOGY (2002)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Dissolved organic carbon losses from grazed grasslands under different management regimes

KB McTiernan et al.

WATER RESEARCH (2001)