The challenge is the complexity-A qualitative study about decision-making in advanced lung cancer treatment

Introduction: The value of shared decision-making and decision aids (DA) has been well documented yet remain difficult to integrate into clinical practice. We wanted to investigate needs and challenges regarding decision making about advanced lung cancer treatment after first-line therapy, focusing on DA applicability.Methods: Qualitative data from separate, semi-structured focus groups with patients/relatives and healthcare professionals were analysed using systematic text condensation. 12 patients with incurable lung cancer, seven relatives, 12 nurses and 18 doctors were recruited from four different hospitals in Norway.Results: The participants described the following needs and challenges affecting treatment decisions: 1) Continuity of clinician-patient-relationships as a basic framework for decision-making; 2) barriers to information exchange; 3) negotiation of autonomy; and 4) assessment of uncertainty and how to deal with it. Some clinicians feared DA would steal valuable time and disrupt consultations, arguing that such tools could not incorporate the complexity and uncertainty of decision-making. Patients and relatives reported a need for more information and the possibility both to decline or continue burdensome therapy. Participants welcomed interventions supporting information exchange, like communicative techniques and organizational changes ensuring continuity and more time for dialogue. Doctors called for tools decreasing uncertainty about treatment tolerance and futile therapy. Conclusion: Our study suggests it is difficult to develop an applicable DA for advanced lung cancer after first-line therapy that meets the composite requirements of stakeholders.Comprehensive decision support interventions are needed to address organizational structures, communication training including scientific and existential uncertainty, and assessment of frailty and treatment toxicity.

Automated summary

This study investigated the needs and challenges of decision-making about advanced lung cancer treatment after first-line therapy, focusing on the applicability of decision aids. The findings revealed the importance of continuity in clinician-patient relationships, overcoming barriers to information exchange, negotiating autonomy, and addressing uncertainty in treatment decisions. Participants expressed the need for more information and support tools to aid decision-making.