A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Basal and Post-Stress Circulating Cortisol Concentration in an Important Marine Aquaculture Fish Species, European Sea Bass, Dicentrarchus labrax

Simple Summary European sea bass is a species with high economic and societal value in the Mediterranean due to its intensive use in aquaculture. However, it is a species characterized by high cortisol levels that show high variation. The present systematic review and meta-analysis collected and examined all the published data on circulating cortisol in this species. The aim of the study was to analyze all published values in order to provide normal values and ranges of plasma cortisol in this species, both in basal and post-acute stress conditions. Results revealed a very high between-study heterogeneity, while it also calculated the pooled levels of cortisol and their confidence intervals for both basal and post-stress conditions. Moreover, results were analyzed based on various parameters that can potentially affect cortisol levels, including technical, such as assay type and rearing unit, as well as biological, such as body size and anesthesia, influences. Background: European sea bass is a species characterized by high and dispersed cortisol levels. The aim of the present study was to analyze all published data on basal and post-acute stress cortisol levels in this species. Methods: For this systematic review and meta-analysis the Web of Science and Scopus databases were searched for papers reporting plasma or serum cortisol levels in E. sea bass, without language or date restrictions. Data were extracted directly for the reported results and were analyzed separately for basal and post-acute stress levels, as well their standardized mean differences (SMD) using random-effects meta-analyses. Results: Of 407 unique records identified, 69 were eligible. Basal cortisol levels had a pooled effect of 88.7 ng mL(-1) (n = 57), while post-acute stress levels were 385.9 ng mL(-1) (n = 34). The average SMD between basal and post-stress was calculated to be 3.02 (n = 22). All analyses had a high between-study heterogeneity. Results for basal and post-stress levels were affected by the assay type and anesthesia prior to blood sampling. Conclusions: Cortisol levels in E. sea bass are higher than most studied fish species and display large heterogeneity. Application of stress led to elevated cortisol levels in all studies examined. In all cases, sources of between-studies heterogeneity were identified.

Automated summary

This study reviewed and analyzed published data on circulating cortisol levels in European sea bass. The study aimed to provide normal values and ranges of plasma cortisol in this species in both basal and post-stress conditions. Results showed high heterogeneity between studies and calculated pooled levels and confidence intervals of cortisol. Factors such as assay type and anesthesia were found to affect cortisol levels.