Use of archived data to derive soil health and water quality indicators for monitoring shifts in natural resources

Current gaps impeding researchers from developing a soil and watershed health nexus include design of long-term field-scale experiments and statistical methodologies that link soil health indicators (SHI) with water quality indicators (WQI). Land cover is often used to predict WQI but may not reflect the effects of previous management such as legacy fertilizer applications, disturbance, and shifts in plant populations) and soil texture. Our research objectives were to use nonparametric Spearman rank-order correlations to identify SHI and WQI that were related across the Fort Cobb Reservoir experimental watershed (FCREW); use the resulting rho (r) and p values (P) to explore potential drivers of SHI-WQI relationships, specifically land use, management, and inherent properties (soil texture, aspect, elevation, slope); and interpret findings to make recommendations regarding assessment of the sustainability of land use and management. The SHI values used in the correlation matrix were weighted by soil texture and land management. The SHI that were significantly correlated with one or more WQI were available water capacity (AWC), Mehlich III soil P, and the sand to clay ratio (S:C). Mehlich III soil P was highly correlated with three WQI: total dissolved solids (TDS) (0.80; P < 0.01), electrical conductivity of water (EC-H2O) (0.79; P < 0.01), and water nitrates (NO3-H2O) (0.76; P < 0.01). The correlations verified that soil texture and management jointly influence water quality (WQ), but the size of the soils dataset prohibited determination of the specific processes. Adoption of conservation tillage and grasslands within the FCREW improved WQ such that water samples met the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) drinking water standards. Future research should integrate current WQI sampling sites into an edge-of-field design representing all management by soil series combinations within the FCREW.

Automated summary

Current gaps impeding soil and watershed health nexus research include a lack of long-term field-scale experiments and statistical methodologies linking soil health indicators with water quality indicators. This study aimed to identify related indicators, explore potential drivers, and make assessment recommendations. Significant correlations were found between specific soil health indicators (AWC, Mehlich III soil P, S:C) and water quality indicators, showing the influence of soil texture and management. Adoption of conservation tillage and grasslands improved water quality in the experimental watershed.