Perchlorate sensing-Can electrochemistry meet the sensitivity of standard methods?

Growing concerns about adverse effects of perchlorate (ClO4-) together with its relatively frequent occurrence the environment demand sensitive analytical methods. It is also anticipated that ClO4- sensors will find their application in future extra-terrestrial missions. Ion chromatography (IC) and mass spectroscopy (MS) provide sufficiently low detection limit (LOD) but lack transportability and field analysis possibility that are provided by most electrochemical analytical methods. On the other side, commercially available potentiometric ion-selective electrodes (ISEs) cannot compete with IC or MS in terms of sensitivity. To answer the question whether (and how) such drawback can be overcome, in this paper electrochemical methods of ClO4-determination are introduced and evaluated. Starting with potentiometric ISEs which can theoretically reach LOD suitable for assessment of WHO-set limits of ClO4-, it is further shown that ISEs operating in voltammetric mode are superior in terms of sensitivity. Next section covers impedimetric and capacitance ClO4- sensors, concluding that they can reach detection limits of IC or MS while retaining their advantages. In further sections related issues are discussed including biosensing or direct electrochemical reduction of perchlorate as well as diversity of (nano)materials applicable for perchlorate sensors preparation. This critical review thus shows that electrochemical ClO4- sensors can reach sensitivity of standard methods while retaining their portability and ease of operation.

Automated summary

This paper introduces and evaluates the application of electrochemical methods in the detection of perchlorate (ClO4-). It shows that ISE and ISE+voltammetric methods are superior to IC and MS in terms of sensitivity, and impedimetric and capacitance methods can achieve detection limits comparable to IC or MS. The paper also discusses related issues such as biosensing and direct electrochemical reduction of perchlorate, as well as the diversity of materials applicable for perchlorate sensors preparation. Overall, the critical review demonstrates that electrochemical ClO4- sensors can achieve the sensitivity of standard methods while retaining their portability and ease of operation.