Clearance as an Early Indicator of Efficacy for Therapeutic Monoclonal Antibodies: Circumventing Dose Selection Challenges in Oncology

Background and ObjectiveThe designs of first-in-human (FIH) studies in oncology (e.g., 3 + 3 dose escalation design) usually do not provide a sufficient sample size to determine the dose-response relationship for efficacy. This study aimed to assess the feasibility of using monoclonal antibody (mAb) clearance as a biomarker for efficacy to facilitate the identification of potentially efficacious doses across cancer types and drug targets. Methods We performed electronic searches of the Drugs@FDA website, the European Medicines Agency website, and PubMed to identify reports of FIH trials of approved mAbs in oncology. The clearance, half-life, and overall response rate (ORR) data for the mAbs at different dose levels were extracted. Results Twenty-five approved mAbs were included in this study. As expected, due to the small sample sizes in FIH studies, there was no clear dose-response for ORR. However, we found a clear negative association between mAb clearance and ORR across tumors/drug targets, and a clear negative dose-clearance relationship, with clearance decreasing and saturated at high dose levels. The approved mAb doses (1-25 mg/kg) are approximately 2-fold the saturation doses (1-10 mg/kg). The associated clearance values at the approved doses vary across different cancers and drug targets (0.17-1.56 L/day), while tend to be similar within a disease/drug target. Anti-CD20 mAbs for B-cell lymphomas show a higher clearance (similar to 1 L/day) than other cancers and targets (e.g., similar to 0.3 L/day for anti-PD-1). Conclusions Clearance of mAbs can be a tumor/drug target-agnostic biomarker for potential anti-tumor activity as clearance decreases with increasing ORR. Our findings shed important insights into target clearance values that may lead to desired efficacy for different cancers and drug targets, which can be used to guide dose selection for the future development of mAbs during FIH oncology studies.

Automated summary

This study aimed to assess the feasibility of using monoclonal antibody (mAb) clearance as a biomarker for efficacy to identify potentially efficacious doses across cancer types and drug targets. The study found a clear negative association between mAb clearance and overall response rate (ORR), as well as a negative dose-clearance relationship. These findings provide important insights for guiding the development of mAbs in oncology studies.