Decline in wild bee species richness associated with honey bee (Apis mellifera L.) abundance in an urban ecosystem

The spatial heterogeneity of urban landscapes, relatively low agrochemical use, and species-rich floral communities often support a surprising diversity of wild pollinators in cities. However, the management of Western honey bees (Apis mellifera L.) in urban areas may represent a new threat to wild bee communities. Urban beekeeping is commonly perceived as an environmentally friendly practice or a way to combat pollinator declines, when high-density beekeeping operations may actually have a negative influence on native and wild bee populations through floral resource competition and pathogen transmission. On the Island of Montr??al, Canada there has been a particularly large increase in beekeeping across the city. Over the years following a large bee diversity survey ending in 2013, there was an influx of almost three thousand honey bee colonies to the city. In this study, we examined the wild bee communities and floral resources across a gradient of honey bee abundances in urban greenspaces in 2020, and compared the bee communities at the same sites before and after the large influx of honey bees. Overall, we found a negative relationship between urban beekeeping, pollen availability, and wild bee species richness. We also found that honey bee abundance had the strongest negative effect on small (inter-tegular span <2.25 mm) wild bee species richness. Small bee species may be at higher risk in areas with abundant honey bee populations as their limited foraging range may reduce their access to floral resources in times of increased competition. Further research on the influence of urban beekeeping on native and wild pollinators, coupled with evidence-based beekeeping regulations, is essential to ensure cities contain sufficient resources to support wild bee diversity alongside managed honey bees.

Automated summary

The spatial heterogeneity of urban landscapes and low agrochemical use support a diversity of wild pollinators in cities. However, urban beekeeping practices may negatively impact native bee communities through competition for resources and pathogen transmission. In Montreal, Canada, there has been a significant increase in beekeeping, which has led to a decrease in pollen availability and wild bee species richness. Small bee species are particularly vulnerable to the abundance of honey bees in urban areas. Further research and evidence-based regulations are necessary to balance the presence of managed honey bees and wild bee diversity in cities.