Embryotoxicity and visual-motor response of functionalized nanostructured hydroxyapatite-based biomaterials in zebrafish (Danio rerio)

Hydroxyapatite (HA) is a biomaterial widely used in biomedical applications. Many studies have shown that ionic substituents can be incorporated into HA to produce a mineral composition more similar to natural bone tissue with more favorable biological characteristics for application in bone regeneration. However, its poten-tially toxic effects need to be evaluated before full approval for human use. For this purpose, an embryotoxicity test was performed on zebrafish according to OECD guideline 236. Zebrafish embryos were exposed to 1 or 3 microspheres of alginate containing nanoparticles of HA and carbonate (CHA), strontium (SrHA), and zinc -substituted HA (ZnHA) from 4 to 120 h post-fertilization (hpf). Lethality and developmental endpoints were evaluated. In addition, larval behavior at 168 hpf was also analyzed to observe whether biomaterials adversely affect optomotor and avoidance responses (neurotoxicity), as well as the oxidative stress pattern through qPCR. After 120 h exposure to all microspheres with different patterns of crystallinity, porosity, nanoparticle size, surface area, and degradation behavior, there was no mortality rate greater than 20%, indicating the non-embryotoxic character of these biomaterials. All experimental groups showed positive optomotor and avoidance responses, which means that embryo exposure to the tested biomaterials had no neurotoxic effects. Furthermore, larvae exposed to one SrHA microsphere showed a better optomotor response than the control. Furthermore, the biomaterials did not change the pattern of mRNA levels of genes related to oxidative stress even after 120 hpf. The growing number of new HA-based biomaterials produced should be accompanied by increased studies to understand the biosafety of these compounds, especially in alternative models, such as zebrafish embryos. These results reinforce our hypothesis that ion-substituted HA biomaterials do not impose toxicological effects, cause development and neuromotor impairment, or increase oxidative stress in zebrafish embryos being useful for medical devices and in the process of bone regeneration.

Automated summary

Hydroxyapatite (HA) is a widely used biomaterial in biomedical applications. Studies have shown that incorporating ionic substituents into HA can produce a composition more similar to natural bone tissue and have favorable biological characteristics for bone regeneration. In this study, an embryotoxicity test was performed on zebrafish embryos exposed to different HA-based biomaterials, and the results showed no embryotoxic effects, neurotoxic effects, or increased oxidative stress. These findings suggest that ion-substituted HA biomaterials are safe and useful for medical devices and bone regeneration.