Impaired cellulose decomposition in a headwater stream receiving subsurface agricultural drainage

Background Agricultural development of former wetlands has resulted in many headwater streams being sourced by subsurface agricultural drainage systems. Subsurface drainage inputs can significantly influence stream environmental conditions, such as temperature, hydrology, and water chemistry, that drive ecological function. However, ecological assessments of subsurface drainage impacts are rare. We assessed the impact of an agricultural drainage system on cellulose decomposition and benthic respiration using a paired stream study in a headwater branch of Nissouri Creek, in Ontario, Canada. Adjacent first order segments sourced by a spring-fed marsh and a cropped field with subsurface drainage, as well as the adjoining trunk segment, were sampled over a year using the cotton strip assay to measure cellulose decomposition and benthic respiration. Results Assessments of cellulose decomposition revealed a one-third reduction in the drainage-sourced segment compared to marsh-sourced segment. Between segment differences in cellulose decomposition were associated with reduced summer temperatures in the drainage-sourced segment. Impacts of stream cooling from the drainage-sourced segment were transmitted downstream as cellulose decomposition was slower than expected throughout the drainage-sourced segment and for several hundred meters down the adjoining trunk segment. Benthic respiration only differed between the drainage- and marsh-sourced segments in spring, when stream temperatures were similar. Conclusions Our findings suggest there may be a widespread reduction in cellulose decomposition in streams across similar agricultural regions where subsurface drainage is prevalent. However, cooling of streams receiving significant amounts of water inputs from subsurface drainage systems may impart increased resiliency to future climate warming.

Automated summary

Agricultural development and subsurface drainage systems can significantly influence stream environmental conditions, such as temperature and water chemistry, which in turn affect ecological function. This study assessed the impact of an agricultural drainage system on cellulose decomposition and benthic respiration in a headwater stream. The results showed that drainage inputs reduced cellulose decomposition, especially in summer, due to stream cooling. The findings suggest that there may be a widespread reduction in cellulose decomposition in streams with subsurface drainage, but increased resiliency to climate warming may occur in streams receiving significant inputs from such systems.