Adequacy of nitrogen-based indicators for assessment of cropping system performance: A modelling study of Danish scenarios

The EU nitrogen expert panel (EUNEP) has proposed nitrogen-based indicators for farm productivity (N output), effi-ciency (NUE) and environmental emissions (N surplus). This model-based study (using the Daisy model) was carried out, i) to study the effects of soil type, soil organic matter (SOM), cropping pre-histories varying in C input, 3-to-4 manure-to-mineral N proportions and ten crop rotations on the N-based indicators, and ii) to evaluate the adequacy of these indicators by establishing quantitative relationships between N surplus, N loss and soil organic N (SON) stock change. The results, averaged over 24-year simulation period, indicated that grass-clover dominant rotations had highest N output and showed a tendency to increase SON stocks when compared with spring-cereal monocultures. For most rotations, the NUE ranged between 70 and 75 %. The SON stocks were mainly influenced by initial SOM and cropping prehistory, and stocks increased only under low initial SOM and low C input cropping pre-history (spring barley). Overall, SON stocks tended to increase under low C input pre-history, coarse sand, low initial SOM and high manure N, however, this combination did not result in highest productivity, NUE, and lowest N losses. The relations between N surplus, N loss and SON stock change were strongly affected by crop rotations, emphasizing that using N surplus as an indicator for N leaching/losses while ignoring changes in SON stocks may result in biased conclusions, e.g. estimated average error for N losses ranged from -45 % (underestimation) for maize monoculture to +50 % (overestimation) for continuous grass-clover ley. The results also imply that the environmental assessment of cropping systems must be improved by combining above indicators with estimation of N loss and SON stock changes. This study provides a detailed account of N balance components/N indicators for diverse crop rotations and their use according to the recommendations of the EUNEP.

Automated summary

The EU nitrogen expert panel has proposed nitrogen-based indicators for farm productivity, efficiency, and environmental emissions. This study used the Daisy model to explore the effects of various factors on these indicators and evaluate their adequacy. The results showed that grass-clover dominant rotations had the highest nitrogen output, and nitrogen utilization efficiency was mainly influenced by initial soil organic matter and cropping prehistory. The study emphasized the importance of considering changes in soil organic nitrogen stocks when assessing nitrogen losses, and suggested that these indicators should be combined with estimation of nitrogen loss and soil organic nitrogen stock changes for a more comprehensive environmental assessment of cropping systems.