Sulfur Geochemistry Destabilizes Population Oscillations of Wild Rice (Zizania palustris)

Elevated inputs of sulfate to freshwater systems can increase sulfide concentrations in anoxic soils and subsequently destabilize aquatic plant populations, but the interactions between sulfate, other geochemical cycles, and interannual plant population cycles are poorly understood. Increased sulfate loading increases mineralization of nitrogen from litter, but the sulfide produced during this process can limit nitrogen uptake by plants. In some cases, iron may mitigate sulfide's impacts on plants by precipitating iron sulfide. We examined the interannual effects of sulfate loading on mesocosm populations of wild rice, an emergent aquatic plant that undergoes population oscillations and is sensitive to sulfide. Using experimental mesocosms with self-perpetuating populations, we investigated how population dynamics respond to manipulations of surface water sulfate (10 mg L-1 or 300 mg L-1), sediment iron (4.3 mg g(-1) or 10.9 mg g(-1) dry weight), and shoot litter (present or removed). Populations exposed to constant 10 mg L-1 sulfate concentrations had stable biomass oscillations of approximately 3-year periods, consistent with previous studies that demonstrated litter-driven oscillations in nitrogen availability. Populations exposed to 300 mg L-1 sulfate concentrations produced fewer and smaller seeds and declined to extinction in 6 years or less. We did not find a strong effect of iron loading or litter removal on wild rice biomass or seed production. Our observations show the potential of elevated surface water sulfate to rapidly destabilize wild rice populations under varying iron and organic carbon concentrations. Plain Language Summary Plants that naturally grow in freshwater do not survive well if the water contains elevated concentrations of sulfate. Sulfate reduction produces sulfide that subsequently inhibits the uptake of nitrogen, an essential plant nutrient. Some annual plants go through boom-bust cycles with years alternating between high and low biomass because nitrogen takes more than a year to be released from dead plant matter. We investigated the combined effect of sulfate and natural biomass cycles on the stability of wild rice populations by growing plants in large tanks and exposing them to high-sulfate and low-sulfate concentrations, high and low iron concentrations, and with plant matter from the previous growing season either returned or removed. Nearly all plant populations exposed to high sulfate had died by 6 years into the experiment, regardless of iron concentration or litter removal. We show a method to analyze population stability with just a few years of data.

Automated summary

Elevated sulfate concentrations can destabilize wild rice populations, while iron and plant litter have little effect.