A Comparative Analysis of Plant-Based Milk Alternatives Part 1: Composition, Sensory, and Nutritional Value

Consumers are becoming increasingly interested in reducing the consumption of animal-based foods for health, sustainability, and ethical reasons. The food industry is developing products from plant-based ingredients that mimic animal-based foods' nutritional and sensory characteristics. In this study, the focus is on plant-based milk alternatives (PBMAs). A potential problem with plant-based diets is the deficiency of important micronutrients, such as vitamin B-12, B-2, and calcium. Therefore, an analysis of micronutrients in PBMAs was conducted to assess their nutritional value. The second main focus was on the sensory description of the PBMAs, done by a trained panel, and instrumental assessment to characterize the sensory attributes. Almond drinks met the daily micronutrient requirements the least, while soy drinks came closest to cow's milk in macro- and micronutrients. The experimentally determined electronic tongue and volatile compound results confirmed the sensory panel's evaluations and could therefore be used as a method for easy and effective assessments of PBMAs. The PBMAs evaluated in this study could not completely replace cow's milk's nutritional and sensory properties. They are products in their own product group and must be evaluated accordingly. Given the variety of products, consumers should experiment and make their decisions regarding the substitution of cow's milk.

Automated summary

Consumers are increasingly interested in reducing animal-based food consumption for health, sustainability, and ethical reasons. This study assesses the nutritional value and sensory characteristics of plant-based milk alternatives. The results show that almond drinks have the lowest micronutrient content, while soy drinks come closest to cow's milk. The experimental analysis also confirms the accuracy of sensory evaluations. Therefore, consumers should experiment with different products when making choices for milk substitutions.