Multi-scale evaluation of global evapotranspiration products derived from remote sensing images: Accuracy and uncertainty

Advances in satellite remote sensing (RS) techniques have greatly prompted the development of large-scale evapotranspiration (ET) models, yielding several freely available global ET products. A comprehensive evaluation on these products is necessary for selecting the most suitable ET products and developing large-scale ET models step forward. In this study, the accuracy and uncertainty of five RS-based global ET products (MOD16, SSEBop, GLEAM, AVHRR, and BESS) were evaluated at multi scales. At point scale their accuracy was evaluated through a direct comparison with in-situ observations from 94 worldwide flux towers. Results indicate that accuracy differences of these five products vary with statistical metrics and land cover types. The combination of all statistics illustrates that GLEAM and AVHRR outperform three other products, which is consistent with the findings of most previous continental-scale studies. The accuracy at basin scale was assessed through water balance analysis across 19 big river basins. BESS is found to be the product that is superior to four other ET products at both monthly and multi-annual scale, which may be related with its low random error at point scale. The uncertainty of these five products at pixel scale was assessed by the three-cornered hat (TCH) method and comparison analysis. The TCH outputs reveal that BESS and SSEBop are the two products with the lowest and largest relative uncertainty, respectively. That explains the good performance of BESS at basin scale from another perspective. As for the two MODIS-based ET products (MOD16 and SSEBop), their accuracy at FLUXNET site scale is comparable in monthly ET estimation. However, SSEBop has special advantage in the capture of multiyear ET patterns. The comparison analysis indicates that SSEBop is the product that agrees best with the ensemble mean not only on a global scale but also in four of the six continents. Our results imply that it is difficult or even impossible to figure out the best ET product in all respects. The selection of ET products for scientific research should consider their performance difference in spatial scale as well as the influence of land cover and climate conditions.

Automated summary

Advances in satellite remote sensing techniques have led to the development of global evapotranspiration models and the production of freely available ET products. This study evaluated the accuracy and uncertainty of five RS-based global ET products at multiple scales, showing variations in accuracy and uncertainty depending on the product and scale.