Symmetries and asymmetries in the topological roles of piscivorous fishes between occurrence networks and food webs

Ecological networks represent the architecture over which diversity is assembled. The compartmentalization of trophic links and the spatial aggregation of species determine ecosystem dynamics and stability. Species traits such as body size or those related to dispersal ability or environmental and trophic niche may determine the role of a species in different ecological networks such as food webs and occurrence networks. However, the empirical analysis of these connections and their determinants were seldom considered. Our study focused on 16 species of piscivorous fishes from 27 water bodies of the Parana River floodplain, which were surveyed between 4 and 20 times over 5 years. Occurrence networks and food webs were built from abundance of species by site and preys by gut content. Using null models and methods for weighted bipartite networks, we evaluated the compartmentalization in both kinds of networks. The topological roles of species in each network along four hydro-climatic conditions were calculated, based on their membership in a module standardized within module connectivity 'z' and between module connectivity 'c' and related to species body size and 30 eco-morphological variables. A significant modular organization in feeding links and species occurrences was detected. While species of larger body size seem to have a main role connecting modules in food webs, the smaller size species foster the connection among spatial aggregations. However, body size was not the main determinant of intra module connectivity. Morphologies associated with linear races (fusiform body) and manoeuvrability (orbicular body) and predation behaviours were consistently related to intra and inter-module connectivity in food webs and occurrence networks. Our results support the modular organization of food webs and occurrence networks of the main consumers of the Parana River floodplain and the trait-related interrelationship among these networks. Furthermore, the dynamic nature of the trait-role association may foster the stable modular structure observed at higher levels. The recognition of the connecting role of the species in the different networks will improve the understanding of their importance in the functioning of ecosystems, thus enhancing the knowledge of the mechanisms shaping biodiversity.

Automated summary

Ecological networks play a crucial role in shaping biodiversity and ecosystem dynamics. In this study, the authors focused on piscivorous fishes in the Parana River floodplain and analyzed their roles in both food webs and occurrence networks. They found a significant modular organization in feeding links and species occurrences, with larger species connecting modules in food webs and smaller species connecting spatial aggregations. Furthermore, they discovered that body size and eco-morphological traits were key factors in determining the connectivity within and between modules. These findings emphasize the importance of understanding the connections between species in different networks for better management and conservation of ecosystems.