Broadleaf retention benefits to bird diversity in mid-rotation conifer production stands

Retention forestry involves saving important forest structures for flora and fauna during the final felling of a stand, including dead wood and variable amounts of living trees, i.e. green tree retention (GTR). Here we evaluate the long-term effects on avian diversity from GTR by surveying forest birds in 32 mid-rotation stands in southern Sweden, in which broadleaf GTR was present or absent. Complementing the many studies that have assessed GTR in clear-cuts, our results indicated that bird assemblages can also benefit from broadleaf GTR several decades after final felling in conifer dominated production stands. The GTR stands harboured a higher bird abundance and species richness than the control stands without GTR, and also appears to have benefited several important guilds, such as broadleaf-associated birds and cavity nesters. However, variation in the number trees retained, the species composition of retained trees, and their environmental context within the stand (e.g. density and proximity of surrounding production trees), limited our capacity to detect threshold requirements for GTR. In summary, our study provides a glimpse into the future as mid-rotation production stands with such old and large retained trees are unusual in today's landscape, but are expected to become more common in the decades to come, in Sweden and many other nations. Our study thereby provides provisional support for the continued and future use of this practice, and indicates that the biodiversity contribution of retention trees continues to occur several decades into the stand's rotation.

Automated summary

Retention forestry, specifically green tree retention, has long-term positive effects on avian diversity, even several decades after final felling in conifer dominated production stands. The presence of broadleaf green tree retention can benefit bird assemblages by increasing their abundance, species richness, and supporting important guilds such as broadleaf-associated birds and cavity nesters. However, factors like the number and species composition of retained trees, as well as their environmental context within the stand, may affect the effectiveness of green tree retention.