Evidence of a Phonon Hall Effect in the Kitaev Spin Liquid Candidate ?-RuCl3

The material ??-RuCl3 has been the subject of intense scrutiny as a potential Kitaev quantum spin liquid, predicted to display Majorana fermions as low-energy excitations. In practice, ??-RuCl3 undergoes a transition to a state with antiferromagnetic order below a temperature TN ??? 7 K, but this order can be suppressed by applying an external in-plane magnetic field of H11 = 7 T. Whether a quantum spin liquid phase exists just above that field is still an open question, but the reported observation of a quantized thermal Hall conductivity at H11 > 7 T by Kasahara and co-workers [Nature (London) 559, 227 (2018)] has been interpreted as evidence of itinerant Majorana fermions in the Kitaev quantum spin liquid state. In this study, we reexamine the origin of the thermal Hall conductivity ??xy in ??-RuCl3. Our measurements of ??xy(T) on several different crystals yield a temperature dependence very similar to that of the phonondominated longitudinal thermal conductivity ??xx(T), for which the natural explanation is that ??xy is also mostly carried by phonons. Upon cooling, ??xx peaks at T ??? 20 K, then drops until TN, whereupon it suddenly increases again. The abrupt increase below TN is attributed to a sudden reduction in the scattering of phonons by low-energy spin fluctuations as these become partially gapped when the system orders. The fact that ??xy also increases suddenly below TN is strong evidence that the thermal Hall effect in ??-RuCl3 is also carried predominantly by phonons. This implies that any quantized signal from Majorana edge modes would have to come on top of a sizable???and sample-dependent???phonon background.

Automated summary

RuCl3 undergoes a transition to a state with antiferromagnetic order below a temperature of about 7 K, but this order can be suppressed by applying an external magnetic field. The existence of a quantum spin liquid phase just above a certain magnetic field is still uncertain, but recent observations suggest the presence of itinerant Majorana fermions.