Developing a Phototactic Electrostatic Insect Trap Targeting Whiteflies, Leafminers, and Thrips in Greenhouses

Simple Summary Silverleaf whiteflies (Bemisia tabaci), vegetable leafminers (Liriomyza sativae), and western flower thrips (Frankliniella occidentalis) are very serious pests of greenhouse tomatoes. In Japan, growers of organic tomatoes currently use large numbers of yellow sticky traps to control insects, but these traps need replacing very regularly, as the sticky surface becomes clogged with insects. An electric field-generating apparatus, described herein, is a potential physical tool to control these pests that have entered greenhouses. The electric field was formed in the space between oppositely electrified insulated conductors arrayed in parallel with fixed separation. Although these conductors created a sufficiently strong force to capture insects entering the field, the force was insufficient to capture insects outside the field. The positive phototaxis of these insects was an inspiration to develop an improved electrostatic insect trap, which was constructed by introducing oppositely charged yellow-colored water into paired transparent insulator tubes to produce opposite poles. The finished apparatus exhibited coloration and insect attraction characteristics similar to commercial yellow sticky traps, but had the advantage that they could be cleaned easily and remain effective for long periods. The surfaces of the insulator tubes containing the charged yellow water were electrostatically active, but not excessively sticky, thus, the apparatus could be placed close to the plants. The close location of the devices enabled preferential attraction of flying or plant-settling insects to the trap. The present study provided an experimental basis for developing an electrostatic device to attract and capture insects that enter greenhouses. Our aim was to develop an electrostatic apparatus to lure and capture silverleaf whiteflies (Bemisia tabaci), vegetable leafminers (Liriomyza sativae), and western flower thrips (Frankliniella occidentalis) that invade tomato greenhouses. A double-charged dipolar electric field producer (DD-EFP) was constructed by filling water in two identical transparent soft polyvinyl chloride tubes arrayed in parallel with fixed separation, and then, inserting the probes of grounded negative and positive voltage generators into the water of the two tubes to generate negatively and positively charged waters, respectively. These charged waters electrified the outer surfaces of the opposite tubes via dielectric polarization. An electric field formed between the oppositely charged tubes. To lure these phototactic insects, the water was colored yellow using watercolor paste, then introduced into the transparent insulator tubes to construct the yellow-colored DD-EFP. This apparatus lured insects in a manner similar to commercially available yellow sticky traps. The yellow-colored DD-EFP was easily placed as a movable upright screen along the plants, such that invading pests were preferentially attracted to the trap before reaching the plants. Furthermore, pests settling on the plants were attracted to the apparatus, which used a plant-tapping method to drive them off the plants. Our study provided an experimental basis for developing an electrostatic device to attract and capture insects that enter greenhouses.

Automated summary

Greenhouse tomatoes are threatened by serious pests like silverleaf whiteflies, vegetable leafminers, and western flower thrips. Researchers have developed an electric field-generating apparatus to attract and capture these pests entering the greenhouse. The apparatus, constructed with oppositely charged yellow-colored water in transparent insulator tubes, effectively attracts insects without excessive stickiness, providing a long-lasting pest control method.