B-factor accuracy in protein crystal structures

The accuracy of B factors in protein crystal structures has been determined by comparing the same atoms in numerous, independent crystal structures of Gallus gallus lysozyme. Both B-factor absolute differences and normal probability plots indicate that the estimated B-factor errors are quite large, close to 9 angstrom(2) in ambient-temperature structures and to 6 angstrom(2) in low-temperature structures, and surprisingly are comparable to values estimated two decades ago. It is well known that B factors are not due to local movements only but reflect several, additional factors from crystal defects, large-scale disorder, diffraction data quality etc. It therefore remains essential to normalize B factors when comparing different crystal structures, although it has clearly been shown that they provide useful information about protein dynamics. Improved, quantitative analyses of raw B factors require novel experimental and computational tools that are able to disaggregate local movements from other features and properties that affect B factors.

Automated summary

The accuracy of B factors in protein crystal structures has been found to have large errors, comparable to values estimated two decades ago. Normalizing B factors is still essential when comparing different crystal structures. Novel experimental and computational tools are needed for improved quantitative analysis of raw B factors.