Democratising Measurement: or Why Thick Concepts Call for Coproduction

Thick concepts, namely those concepts that describe and evaluate simultaneously, present a challenge to science. Since science does not have a monopoly on value judgments, what is responsible research involving such concepts? Using measurement of wellbeing as an example, we first present the options open to researchers wishing to study phenomena denoted by such concepts. We argue that while it is possible to treat these concepts as technical terms, or to make the relevant value judgment in-house, the responsible thing to do, especially in the context of public policy, is to make this value judgment through a legitimate political process that includes all the stakeholders of this research. We then develop a participatory model of measurement based on the ideal of co-production. To show that this model is feasible and realistic, we illustrate it with a case study of co-production of a concept of thriving conducted by the authors in collaboration with a UK anti-poverty charity Turn2us.

Automated summary

Thick concepts, which describe and evaluate simultaneously, present a challenge to science. Researchers can either treat these concepts as technical terms or make value judgments internally, but a responsible approach, especially in the context of public policy, is to make value judgments through a legitimate political process. A participatory measurement model can achieve this goal.