Leveraging slow DOTA f-element complexation kinetics to enable separations by kinetic design

The design of metal-concerned solvent extraction systems frequently leverages thermodynamically derived differences in selectivity. An alternative approach, leveraging kinetic control, has been considered much less seriously. Our recent manuscript describing DOTA (1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclododecane-1,4,7,10-tetraacetic acid) complexation kinetics across the lanthanide series shows the observed rate constant steadily increases across the series, with some non-monotonic behavior observed at terbium and thulium. This contrasts the thermodynamic stability constant trend, where lanthanide-DOTA stability constants initially increase and then plateau as a function of ionic radii after samarium. To leverage the kinetic differences of DOTA with the lanthanides across the series, kinetically based separations must be utilized. Since DOTA has very slow complexation kinetics, a separations system must expedite DOTA-metal complexation to allow a separation approximating practical application. In this report, a DOTA-based solvent extraction system, where DOTA is the aqueous holdback reagent and bis-2,4,4-trimethylpentylphosphinic acid (Cyanex 272) is the organic phase extractant, is demonstrated and compares the separations chemistry of Nd, Eu and Am. The slowness of DOTA complexation was addressed by heating the system. Results showed, in general, separation between metals is better during early phase contact, and diminishes under longer contact times. Under all conditions, separations are better than would be predicted based on a thermodynamic basis. This report suggests that while slowly complexing ligands classically used for biological applications may not be appropriate for thermodynamically designed metal separations, their use for kinetically based systems may be appropriate and enable a new design basis for f-element separations.

Automated summary

This study explores a new approach using kinetic control in metal ion extraction systems, showing that the rate constant of lanthanide-DOTA complexes increases with the lanthanide series, exhibiting non-monotonic behavior in terbium and thulium. Results suggest that separations between metals are more effective in the early phase of contact, diminishing over longer contact times. The use of slowly complexing ligands like DOTA may be suitable for kinetically based systems, providing a new design basis for f-element separations.