Journal
PROCEEDINGS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY B-BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES
Volume 288, Issue 1964, Pages -Publisher
ROYAL SOC
DOI: 10.1098/rspb.2021.2121
Keywords
thermal performance; acclimation; critical thermal limits; individual variation; phenotypic plasticity
Categories
Funding
- Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada [RGPIN-2018-05322]
- Canada Graduate Scholarship
- Canadian Foundation for Innovation
- Ontario Research Fund
Ask authors/readers for more resources
The study found that although the relationship between basal tolerance and plasticity was not significant in non-acclimated flies, there was still a strong correlation between the two in cold-acclimated flies, which may be influenced by statistical artifact. This suggests that previous patterns of thermal tolerance trade-off in similar studies may be affected by regression to the mean effects. Control and correction for such effects are crucial in determining the existence of a trade-off or physiological constraint.
The thermotolerance-plasticity trade-off hypothesis predicts that ectotherms with greater basal thermal tolerance have a lower acclimation capacity. This hypothesis has been tested at both high and low temperatures but the results often conflict. If basal tolerance constrains plasticity (e.g. through shared mechanisms that create physiological constraints), it should be evident at the level of the individual, provided the trait measured is repeatable. Here, we used chill-coma onset temperature and chill-coma recovery time (CCO and CCRT; non-lethal thermal limits) to quantify cold tolerance of Drosophila melanogaster across two trials (pre- and post-acclimation). Cold acclimation improved cold tolerance, as expected, but individual measurements of CCO and CCRT in non-acclimated flies were not (or only slightly) repeatable. Surprisingly, however, there was still a strong correlation between basal tolerance and plasticity in cold-acclimated flies. We argue that this relationship is a statistical artefact (specifically, a manifestation of regression to the mean; RTM) and does not reflect a true trade-off or physiological constraint. Thermal tolerance trade-off patterns in previous studies that used similar methodology are thus likely to be impacted by RTM. Moving forward, controlling and/or correcting for RTM effects is critical to determining whether such a trade-off or physiological constraint exists.
Authors
I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.
Reviews
Recommended
No Data Available