A randomised controlled trial evaluating two universal prevention programs for children: Building resilience to manage worry

Background: Childhood anxiety and depression lead to great distress and impairment. Preventing them simultaneously in early life is critically important. We evaluated the long-term efficacy of an emotion regulation-based (ER) and a behavioural activation-based (BA) program. Both aimed to build resilience to prevent worry, a transdiagnostic feature across anxiety and depression. Methods: Participants were 316 students (52.2% female; 8-13 years) from six South Australian primary schools. Schools were randomised to the ER, BA or a control condition. Measures of resilience, worry, anxiety, and depression were taken at pre- and post- program, and at 6- and 12-month follow-up. In addition, levels of emotion regulation, behavioural activation and resilience were measured as potential mediators of changes in anxiety and depression. Results: No significant condition x time interactions were observed. However, the percentage of children who met the clinical cut-offs for generalised anxiety disorder and major depressive disorder decreased significantly in the BA condition at 12-month follow-up, as well as the percentage of children who met the clinical cut-off for obsessive compulsive disorder in the ER condition. Furthermore, emotion regulation mediated the relationship between condition and worry at post-program in the ER condition. Limitations: The sample size is relatively small. Reliance on child self-report may have resulted in inaccurate responses. Conclusion: The ER and BA transdiagnostic prevention programs for childhood anxiety and depression showed promising results for certain anxiety disorders not otherwise observed in universal school-based studies. Future research should consider evaluating the programs with a larger sample using alternative outcome measures.

Automated summary

This study evaluated the long-term efficacy of emotion regulation-based and behavioural activation-based programs for preventing childhood anxiety and depression. The results showed promising results for certain anxiety disorders. However, the sample size was relatively small, and further research with larger samples and alternative outcome measures is needed to evaluate these programs.