Direct Drive Applications: Possible Replacement of Rare-Earth Permanent Magnet Motors

This paper deals with the possibility to replace rare-earth permanent magnet (PM) motors in direct drive applications. According to previous researches, there are alternatives such as surface-mounted PM motors and spoke-type motors adopting Ferrite PMs, synchronous reluctance motors, with or without the assistance of low-energy PMs. Few studies have been carried out to compare all models at once, thus it is hard to choose which type motor is to be preferred as a valid alternative of rare-earth PM motors in direct drive applications. In this paper, the representative candidates listed above are analyzed and the results are compared with that of a rare-earth PM motor, which is considered as a reference motor. Additionally, the demagnetization phenomenon of the motors with Ferrite PMs is deeply analyzed because this kind of PM may be easily demagnetized by the stator flux. Finally, both strengths and weaknesses of each alternative motors are highlighted.

Automated summary

This paper discusses the possibility of replacing rare-earth permanent magnet motors in direct drive applications, comparing the strengths and weaknesses of various alternatives. Specifically, the demagnetization phenomenon of motors with Ferrite PMs is deeply analyzed.