BoxCar and Library-Free Data-Independent Acquisition Substantially Improve the Depth, Range, and Completeness of Label-Free Quantitative Proteomics

Data-dependent acquisition (DDA) methods are the current standard for quantitative proteomics in many biological systems. However, DDA preferentially measures highly abundant proteins and generates data that is plagued with missing values, requiring extensive imputation. Here, we demonstrate that library-free BoxCarDIA acquisition, combining MS1-level BoxCar acquisition with MS2-level data-independent acquisition (DIA) analysis, outperforms conventional DDA and other library-free DIA (directDIA) approaches. Using a combination of low- (HeLa cells) and high-(Arabidopsis thaliana cell culture) dynamic range sample types, we demonstrate that BoxCarDIA can achieve a 40% increase in protein quantification over DDA without offline fractionation or an increase in mass-spectrometer acquisition time. Further, we provide empirical evidence for substantial gains in dynamic range sampling that translates to deeper quantification of low-abundance protein classes under-represented in DDA and directDIA data. Unlike both DDA and directDIA, our new BoxCarDIA method does not require full MS1 scans while offering reproducible protein quantification between replicate injections and providing more robust biological inferences. Overall, our results advance the BoxCarDIA technique and establish it as the new method of choice for label-free quantitative proteomics across diverse sample types.

Automated summary

This study demonstrates the advantages of library-free BoxCarDIA acquisition method in quantitative proteomics, which achieves better protein quantification for low-abundance proteins and offers more robust biological inferences compared to DDA and directDIA methods, without requiring full MS1 scans.