Evaluating the New Common Agricultural Policy: Improving the Rules

Thirty years after their conception and adoption, European rural development policies are about to enter a new programming period, splitting away from the cohesion funds and showing, for the first time since the implementation of agricultural policies, real integration with the so-called first Pillar of the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP). The proposal for the new CAP from 2023-2027 includes some improvements through a new delivery model and organisational approach, which may reinforce future evaluations. As to overseeing the implementation of the CAP, the Commission proposed to move from a compliance-based to a performance-based approach. Nevertheless, we can highlight some elements that may weaken evaluation processes, with the risk of repeating past failures, as is the case in the current CAP programming period from 2014-2020. This article analyses the new framework proposed for the evaluation of the future CAP and is intended to promote a discussion on how to make evaluations more usable, useful and reliable for their users and evaluation practitioners. The analysis concerns only the rules for evaluation and does not discuss other specific monitoring, performance framework and control requirements, which are interrelated with evaluation.

Automated summary

The article discusses the new framework proposed for the evaluation of the future CAP, highlighting some improvements but also pointing out factors that may weaken the evaluation process. The focus is on how to make evaluations more usable, useful, and reliable.