4.2 Article

FROM BEST INTERESTS TO BETTER INTERESTS? VALUES, UNWISDOM AND OBJECTIVITY IN MENTAL CAPACITY LAW

Journal

CAMBRIDGE LAW JOURNAL
Volume 80, Issue 2, Pages 245-273

Publisher

CAMBRIDGE UNIV PRESS
DOI: 10.1017/S0008197321000283

Keywords

mental capacity; best interests; unwise decisions; objective values; subjective values; personal decision-making

Categories

Funding

  1. Arts and Humanities Research Council [AH/R013055/1]
  2. AHRC [AH/R013055/1] Funding Source: UKRI

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The Mental Capacity Act 2005 governs personal decision-making for adults and includes five overarching principles, emphasizing that incapacity cannot solely be inferred from unwise decisions and decisions must be made in the best interests of the person lacking capacity. Analysis of judicial treatment, parliamentary debates, and philosophical critique reveals that these principles are problematically irreconcilable, with the Act's radical under-specificity leading to resolution through abstract values rather than the individual themselves.
The Mental Capacity Act 2005 governs personal decision-making for adults. It incorporates five overarching principles, including that incapacity may not be inferred merely from a person's unwise decisions and that where a person lacks capacity decisions must be made in her best interests. Through analysis of judicial treatment of unwisdom, best interests, subjectivity and objectivity, considered against parliamentary debates on the Mental Capacity Bill and philosophical critique of ideas of (un)wisdom, we argue that these principles are problematically irreconcilable. The Act's radical under-specificity means, paradoxically, that this comes to be resolved through abstracted values, rather than the centricity of the person herself.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.2
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

No Data Available
No Data Available