Journal
HEALTH SERVICES RESEARCH
Volume 51, Issue -, Pages 1248-1272Publisher
WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/1475-6773.12503
Keywords
Patient narratives; patient experiences; public reporting; consumers; qualitative methods; patient-centered care
Funding
- AHRQ [1R21HS021858, 2U18HS016980, 1U18HS016978]
Ask authors/readers for more resources
Objective. To design a methodology for rigorously eliciting narratives about patients' experiences with clinical care that is potentially useful for public reporting and quality improvement. Data Sources/Study Setting. Two rounds of experimental data (N = 48 each) collected in 2013-2014, using a nationally representative Internet panel. Study Design. Our study (1) articulates and operationalizes criteria for assessing narrative elicitation protocols; (2) establishes a gold standard for assessment of such protocols; and (3) creates and tests a protocol for narratives about outpatient treatment experiences. Data Collection/Extraction Methods. We randomized participants between telephone and web-based modalities and between protocols placed before and after a closed-ended survey. Principal Findings. Elicited narratives can be assessed relative to a gold standard using four criteria: (1) meaningfulness, (2) completeness, (3) whether the narrative accurately reflects the balance of positive and negative events, and (4) representativeness, which reflects the protocol's performance across respondent subgroups. We demonstrate that a five-question protocol that has been tested and refined yields three-to sixfold increases in completeness and four-to tenfold increases in meaningfulness, compared to a single open-ended question. It performs equally well for healthy and sick patients. Conclusions. Narrative elicitation protocols suitable for inclusion in extant patient experience surveys can be designed and tested against objective performance criteria, thus advancing the science of public reporting.
Authors
I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.
Reviews
Recommended
No Data Available