Effects of ad libitum food intake, insufficient sleep and weekend recovery sleep on energy balance

Study Objectives: Insufficient sleep is believed to promote positive energy balance (ER) and weight gain. Increasing weekend sleep duration to recover from weekday sleep loss is common, yet little is known regarding how weekend recovery sleep influences EB. We conducted a randomized controlled trial to assess how: (1) 2 days and 8 days of insufficient sleep and (2) ad libitum weekend recovery sleep impact EB (energy intake [EI] - energy expenditure [EE]). Methods: Following ten baseline days with 9 h per night sleep opportunities, participants completed one of three 10-day experimental protocols with ad libitum EI: control (9 h sleep opportunities; n = 8; 23 +/- 5 years [mean +/- SD]); sleep restriction (SR; 5 h sleep opportunities; n = 14; 25 +/- 5 years); sleep restriction with weekend recovery sleep (SR + WR; 5 days insufficient sleep, 2 days ad libitum weekend recovery sleep, 3 days recurrent insufficient sleep; n =14; 27 +/- 4 years). Results: Twenty-four hour ER increased (p < 0.001; main effect) by an average of 797.7 +/- 96.7 (+/- SEM) kcal during the 10-day experimental protocol versus baseline with no significant differences between groups. Percent change from baseline in 24 h-EE was higher (p < 0.05) on day 2 of insufficient sleep (SR and SR + WR groups; 10 +/- 1%) versus adequate sleep (control group; 4 +/- 3%). Conclusions: In this between-group study, the effects of adequate sleep and insufficient sleep, with or without or weekend recovery sleep, on 24 h-EB were similar. Examining EB and body weight changes using within-subject cross-over designs and free-living conditions outside the laboratory (e.g. sleep extension) are needed to advance our understanding of the links between insufficient sleep, weekend recovery sleep and weight-gain.

Automated summary

The study found that increasing weekend recovery sleep does not improve the positive energy balance and weight gain caused by insufficient sleep.