A three-dimensional printed model in preoperative consent for ventricular septal defect repair

Background The 3D printing technology in congenital cardiac surgery has been widely utilized to improve patients' understanding of their disease. However, there has been no randomized controlled study on its usefulness in surgical consent for congenital heart disease repair. Methods A randomized controlled study was performed during consent process in which guardians of candidates for ventricular septal defect repair were given detailed explanation of the anatomy, indication for surgery and potential complication and risks using 3D print ventricular septal defect model (n = 20) versus a conventional 2D diagram (n = 20). A questionnaire was finished by each guardian of the patients. Data collected from questionnaires as well as medical records were statistically analyzed. Results Statistically significant improvements in ratings of understanding of ventricular septal defect anatomy (p = 0.02), and of the surgical procedure and potential complications (p = 0.02) were noted in the group that used the 3D model, though there was no difference in overall ratings of the consent process (p = 0.09). There was no difference in questionnaire score between subjects with different education levels. The clinical outcomes, as represented by the duration of intensive care unit stay, intubation duration was comparable between the two groups. Conclusions The results indicated that it was an effective tool which may be used to consent for congenital heart surgery. Different education levels do not affect guardians' understanding in consent. The impact of 3D printing used in this scenario on long term outcomes remains to be defined.

Automated summary

The use of 3D printing in surgical consent process for congenital heart disease repair can significantly improve guardians' understanding of disease anatomy and surgical procedures. Education levels do not affect guardians' comprehension, and clinical outcomes are similar between the 3D model and 2D diagram groups. Long-term outcomes of 3D printing in this context require further investigation.