Effects of thinning on the demography and functional community structure of a secondary tropical lowland rain forest

Tropical secondary forests play a prominent role in conserving biodiversity and providing ecosystem services, but their recovery can be slow and their succession trajectory is distinct from old-growth forests. Thinning is an essential silvicultural approach to enhance the recovery rate and timber production of forests. However, the selection of trees to thin has been mainly based on size class rather than on species identity. There is little empirical or experimental evidence of species-focused thinning with the goal of altering species composition. We examined the effects of thinning on community structure, demographic rates, species richness and functional diversity of woody plants in a detailed investigation of 60-year-old secondary tropical lowland rain forest on Hainan Island, South China. The density and basal area of trees >= 5 cm DBH (diameter at breast height) increased significantly after five years' recovery with no significant change for saplings (DBH < 5 cm). Species composition after thinning changed significantly and mid-to late-successional species of both saplings and trees were more abundant after five years' recovery. The relative growth rates (RGR) and recruitment rates were significantly higher in thinning plots for both saplings and trees, and RGRs increased by 127% and 48%, respectively. The mortality rate decreased by 13% for trees and increased by 47% for saplings in thinning plots compared to the control. The community weighted mean (CWM) of the specific leaf area (SLA) of saplings showed a significantly decreasing trend while CWMs of wood density (WD) and mean maximum height (Hmax) of saplings increased after thinning. By contrast, CWMs of SLA and Hmax of trees were significantly higher, but WD was significantly lowerin thinning plots than the control. RGR and recruitment rate of saplings and trees increased significantly as thinning intensity increased. However, the thinning intensity had a weak or nil effect on the mortality rate. Our results support the selective removal and girdling of pioneer and mid-successional species in a way that could accelerate recovery and improve the growth and recruitment of late-successional species in tropical secondary forests. Thinning at a relatively low intensity can maintain species diversity and alter species functional composition. This outcome shows promise for improved future management of tropical forests in human modified tropical forest landscapes.

Automated summary

Thinning of tropical secondary forests can change the community structure of woody plants, increase species richness and functional diversity, and promote the growth and recruitment of late-successional species. Thinning has a significant impact on the relative growth rates and recruitment rates of saplings and trees, but has a weaker effect on mortality rates.