Pinus sylvestris L. and Fagus sylvatica L. effects on soil and root properties and their interactions in a mixed forest on the Southwestern Pyrenees

Tree species alter soil properties, potentially modifying forest nutrients cycling. In the current management context in which mixed species forests are favoured over monocultures due to their biodiversity and productivity-related advantages, the assessment of species effects on soils, as well as their interactions with other species, gains increasing relevance. In this study, the effects of Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) and European beech (Fagus sylvatica L.) on soil properties were evaluated. Fine roots were paid special attention, measuring their biomass, functional traits (specific root length, root tissue density) and vertical distribution in order to discern the direction of these species interaction, either complementary or competitive. The research was carried out in the Southwestern Pyrenees (northern Spain), in an originally Scots pine stand transformed nowadays into a mixed forest by European beech natural regeneration. Soil and root samples were taken close to pine trees surrounded by other pines in areas that remain similar to pine monospecific stands, and close to pine and beech trees surrounded by both species in mixed areas. A lower C/N ratio was found in the soil close to beech stems. This suggests better quality in mixed litter in comparison to pine litter, leading to higher decomposition rates. Higher fine mot biomass was found in the mixed areas mainly due to beech fine roots great abundance, which correlated positively with microbial biomass. Fine roots functional traits such as specific root length and diameter did not vary depending on their proximity to different tree species, though Scots pine fine root biomass decreased sharply when close to beech trees. This reduction, together with the already more abundant fine root biomass of beech, with higher specific root length and mot tissue density than pine, lead to a competitive interaction in which European beech tends to dominate the soil at all depths. In this case, no complementarity effect at belowground level, strong enough to allow Scots pines to cope with beech soil colonization, was found under natural conditions.

Automated summary

Tree species, such as Scots pine and European beech, have different effects on soil properties, with beech showing a competitive advantage in terms of soil dominance and higher fine root biomass in mixed areas, leading to higher decomposition rates and microbial biomass.