Simplified Transition and Turbulence Modeling for Oscillatory Pipe Flows

One-dimensional unsteady Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes computations were performed for oscillatory transitional and turbulent pipe flows and the results were validated against existing experimental data for a wide variety of oscillatory Reynolds and Womersley numbers. An unsteady version of the Johnson-King model was implemented with optional near-wall modification to account for temporal pressure gradient variations, and the predictions were compared with those of the Spalart-Allmaras and k-epsilon turbulence models. Transition and relaminarization were based on empirical Womersley number correlations and assumed to occur instantaneously: in the former case, this assumption was valid, but in the latter case, deviations between data and predictions were observed. In flows where the oscillatory Reynolds numbers are substantially higher than the commonly accepted steady critical value (similar to 2000), fully or continuously turbulent models produced the best correspondence with experimental data. Critically and conditionally turbulent models produced slightly inferior correspondence, and no significant benefit was observed when near-wall pressure gradient effects were implemented or when common one- and two-equation turbulence models were employed. The turbulent velocity profiles were mainly unaffected by the oscillations and this was explained by noting that the turbulent viscosity is significantly higher than its laminar counterpart. Thus, a turbulent Womersley number was proposed for the analysis and categorization of oscillatory pipe flows.

Automated summary

One-dimensional unsteady Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes computations were conducted for oscillatory transitional and turbulent pipe flows, showing that fully or continuously turbulent models had the best agreement with experimental data when oscillatory Reynolds numbers were substantially higher than 2000, while critically and conditionally turbulent models had slightly inferior correspondence.