A Series of Data-Driven Hypotheses for Inferring Biogeochemical Conditions in Alkaline Lakes and Their Deposits Based on the Behavior of Mg and SiO2

Alkaline (pH > 8.5) lakes have been common features of Earth's surface environments throughout its history and are currently among the most biologically productive environments on the planet. The chemistry of alkaline lakes favors the deposition of aluminum-poor magnesian clays (e.g., sepiolite, stevensite, and kerolite) whose chemistry and mineralogy may provide a useful record of the biogeochemistry of the lake waters from which they were precipitated. In this forward-looking review, we present six data-driven, testable hypotheses devoted to furthering our understanding of the biogeochemical conditions in paleolake waters based on the geochemical behavior of Mg and SiO2. In the development of these hypotheses, we bring together a compilation of modern lake water chemistry, recently published and new experimental data, and empirical, thermodynamic, and kinetic relationships developed from these data. We subdivide the hypotheses and supporting evidence into three categories: (1) interpreting paleolake chemistry from mineralogy; (2) interpreting the impact of diatoms on alkaline lake sedimentation; and (3) interpreting depositional mineralogy based on water chemistry. We demonstrate the need for further investigation by discussing evidence both for and against each hypothesis, which, in turn, highlights the gaps in our knowledge and the importance of furthering our understanding of the relevant geological and biological systems. The focused testing of these hypotheses against modern occurrences and the geologic record of alkaline lakes can have profound implications for the interpretation of the paleo-biogeochemistry and paleohabitability of these systems on Earth and beyond.

Automated summary

Alkaline lakes have been common on Earth's surface and are highly biologically productive. The deposition of minerals can provide insight into the biogeochemical conditions of ancient lake waters. By proposing six data-driven hypotheses, this review aims to further understand the geochemical behavior of ancient lake waters through mineralogy and diatom impact on sedimentation.