How do cognitive processes influence script concordance test responses?

Introduction The script concordance test (SCT) is a test of clinical decision-making (CDM) that compares the thought process of learners to that of experts to determine to what extent their cognitive 'scripts' align. Without understanding test-takers' cognitive process, however, it is unclear what influences their responses. The objective of this study was to gather response process validity evidence by studying the cognitive process of test-takers to determine whether the SCT tests CDM and what cognitive processes may influence SCT responses. Methods Cases from an SCT used in a national validation study were administered and semi-structured cognitive interviews were conducted with ten residents and five staff surgeons. A retrospective verbal probing technique was used. Data was independently analysed and coded by two analysts. Themes were identified as factors that influence SCT responses during the cognitive interview. Results Cognitive interviews demonstrated variability in CDM among test-takers. Consistent with dual process theory, test-takers relied on scripts formed through past experiences, when available, to make decisions and used conscious deliberation in the absence of experience. However, test-takers' response process was also influenced by their comprehension of specific terms, desire for additional information, disagreement with the planned management, underlying knowledge gaps and desire to demonstrate confidence or humility. Conclusion The rationale behind SCT answers may be influenced by comprehension, underlying knowledge and social desirability in addition to formed scripts and/or conscious deliberation. Having test-takers verbalise their rationale for responses provides a depth of assessment that is otherwise lost in the SCT's current format. With the improved ability to standardise CDM assessment using the SCT, consideration of test-makers improving the SCT construction process and combining the SCT question format with verbal responses may improve the use of the SCT for CDM assessment.

Automated summary

The study aimed to gather validity evidence by studying the cognitive process of test-takers to determine whether the SCT tests CDM and what cognitive processes may influence SCT responses. Results showed variability in decision-making among test-takers, with reliance on scripts formed through past experiences and conscious deliberation in the absence of experience. Other influences on SCT responses included comprehension of terms, desire for additional information, disagreement with management plans, knowledge gaps, and desire to show confidence or humility.