Journal
BIOLOGICAL CONTROL
Volume 152, Issue -, Pages -Publisher
ACADEMIC PRESS INC ELSEVIER SCIENCE
DOI: 10.1016/j.biocontrol.2020.104427
Keywords
Host range; Non-target risk; PSV; STD; Specificity index; Aleurotrachelus trachoides; Lobesia botrana
Categories
Funding
- Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada (ABASE) [1526]
Ask authors/readers for more resources
The importance of evaluating the specificity of natural enemies for biological control programs is emphasized, with the proposal of two quantitative metrics to compare candidate biological control agents regarding their host ranges. The study demonstrates the mathematical relationship between these metrics and their application in case studies, providing open source code for calculation. While acknowledging the limitations, the metrics are seen as valuable tools to consider the phylogenetic component of host range when ranking prospective biological control agents.
The need to prevent negative impacts of importation biological control on native biodiversity has made evaluating the specificity (host range) of natural enemies a central issue for the application of biological control programs against pest organisms. Thus, when there are a number of candidate species being considered for introduction as biological control agents against a particular target pest, it is important to compare their relative host ranges. These comparisons are usually made informally using categorical terminology (e.g., generalist, specialist, oligophagous). However, relative differences in natural enemy host range are better expressed quantitatively, with both ecological (how many host species a natural enemy is capable of exploiting) and evolutionary (how the host species are related phylogenetically) components. We propose using two previously developed quantitative taxonomic and phylogenetic metrics (taxonomic host range - STD; phylogenetic species variability - PSV), in combination with the number of associated host species (host species richness), as heuristic tools to rank the relative host specificity of candidate biological control agents. We first show that although STD and PSV were developed independently, they are directly related mathematically and convey exactly the same information except on different numerical scales. We then apply the metrics to case studies regarding the host range of candidate biological control agents for: (i) an invasive whitefly in greenhouse crops, Aleurotrachelus trachoides (Hemiptera: Aleyrodidae), and (ii) an invasive pest of grapes, Lobesia botrana (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae). We also provide open source code to easily allow the calculation of these metrics for any natural enemy for which taxonomic host range information is available. Finally, we describe potential uses of these metrics in applied biological control as well as important caveats and limitations that require further theoretical work to address. We conclude that while these metrics should not be considered as absolute or infallible measurements of host range, their application should encourage biological control practitioners to explicitly consider the phylogenetic component of host range when ranking prospective candidate biological control agents.
Authors
I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.
Reviews
Recommended
No Data Available