Comparison of Early Oral Cancer Depth of Invasion From the American Joint Committe on Cancer 7th to 8th Edition Criteria. Does the Difference Impact the Accuracy of Clinical Decision Making?

Purpose: Depth of invasion (DOI) is an independent predictor of regional metastasis in oral squamous cell carcinoma. Measurement criteria for DOI were modified in the American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) eighth edition. The purpose of this study was to compare DOI AJCC seventh (DOI7) and eighth (DOI8) edition criteria on frozen section accuracy for decisions regarding elective neck dissection (END) in cT1N0 oral squamous cell carcinoma. Patients and Methods: A blinded, retrospective, comparative study of patients who underwent ablative surgery at the University of Michigan was completed. The predictor variable was criteria for DOI measurement. The outcome variables were concordance between DOI7 and DOI8 measurements and accuracy using thresholds for END. Effect of tumor growth pattern and worst pattern of invasion, and the difference between DOI8 on frozen and permanent specimen were assessed. Results: A total of 30 specimens of T1N0 oral squamous cell carcinoma (16 tongue, 5 alveolus, 5 floor of mouth, 4 buccal mucosa) were included. DOI7 versus DOI8 on frozen and permanent specimen were significantly different (P < .05) but clinically insignificant and highly correlated (r > 0.99, P < .001). One hundred percent concordance between DOI7 and DOI8 was noted on frozen specimen in predicting the need for END when compared with permanent pathology DOI. There was no significant impact of tumor growth pattern or worst pattern of invasion on measurements and no significant difference in DOI on frozen and permanent specimen for DOI8 (P = .68). Excellent agreement between pathologists for all measurements was observed (ICC>0.99, P < 0001). Conclusions: High concordance between DOI measurements by AJCC seventh and eighth edition criteria suggests that guidelines for DOI thresholds for END in patients with T1N0 tumors developed using the AJCC seventh edition can be safely applied using AJCC eighth edition criteria. DOI measurement by AJCC 8 criteria on frozen specimen can be used to guide decision-making regarding END, given the high correlation to AJCC 8 permanent DOI measurement. (C) 2020 American Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons

Automated summary

Comparison of DOI measurements using AJCC seventh and eighth edition criteria showed high concordance, supporting the safe application of eighth edition criteria for decision-making regarding elective neck dissection in patients with T1N0 tumors.