Patterns of ectoparasite infection in wild-caught and laboratory-bred cichlid fish, and their hybrids, implicate extrinsic rather than intrinsic causes of species differences in infection

Parasite-mediated selection may initiate or enhance differentiation between host populations that are exposed to different parasite infections. Variation in infection among populations may result from differences in host ecology (thereby exposure to certain parasites) and/or intrinsic immunological traits. Species of cichlid fish, even when recently diverged, often differ in parasite infection, but the contributions of intrinsic and extrinsic causes are unknown. Here, we compare infection patterns between two closely related host species from Lake Victoria (genusPundamilia), using wild-caught and first-generation laboratory-reared fish, as well as laboratory-reared hybrids. Three of the commonest ectoparasite species observed in the wild were also present in the laboratory populations. However, the infection differences between the host species as observed in the wild were not maintained in laboratory conditions. In addition, hybrids did not differ in infection from either parental species. These findings suggest that the observed species differences in infection in the wild might be mainly driven by ecology-related effects (i.e. differential exposure), rather than by intrinsic species differences in immunological traits. Thus, while there is scope for parasite-mediated selection inPundamiliain the wild, it has apparently not yet generated divergent evolutionary responses and may not enhance assortative mating among closely related species.

Automated summary

Parasite-mediated selection may not lead to divergent evolutionary responses and assortative mating among closely related species, as observed differences in infection in the wild between two closely related cichlid fish species in Lake Victoria appear to be mainly driven by ecology-related effects rather than intrinsic species differences in immunological traits. Hybrids did not differ in infection from either parental species, suggesting that parasite-mediated selection in the wild may not be generating significant evolutionary outcomes at this point.