Structure of a tRNA-specific deaminase with compromised deamination activity

Nucleotide 34 in tRNA is extensively modified to ensure translational fidelity and efficacy in cells. The deamination of adenosine at this site catalyzed by the enzyme TadA gives rise to inosine (I), which serves as a typical example of the wobble hypothesis due to its diverse basepairing capability. However, recent studies have shown that tRNAArg ACG in Mycoplasma capricolum contains unmodified adenosine, in order to decode the CGG codon. The structural basis behind the poorly performing enzyme M. capricolum TadA (McTadA) is largely unclear. Here we present the structures of the WT and a mutant form of McTadA determined at high resolutions. Through structural comparison between McTadA and other active TadA enzymes as well as modeling efforts, we found that McTadA presents multiple structural conflicts with RNA substrates and thus offered support to previous studies from a structural perspective. These clashes would potentially lead to reduced substrate binding affinity of McTadA, consistent with our in vitro deamination activity and binding assays. To rescue the deamination activity of McTadA, we carried out two rounds of protein engineering through structure-guided design. The unsuccessful attempts of the activity restoration could be attributed to the altered dimer interface and stereo hindrance from the non-catalytic subunit of McTadA, which could be the inevitable outcome of the natural evolution. Our study provides structural insight into an alternative decoding and evolutionary strategy by a compromised TadA enzyme at a molecular level.