Journal
JOURNAL OF NEUROSCIENCE
Volume 40, Issue 4, Pages 864-879Publisher
SOC NEUROSCIENCE
DOI: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.1904-19.2019
Keywords
decision variable correlation; efficiency; motion energy; natural scene statistics; psychophysics; signal detection theory
Categories
Funding
- University of Pennsylvania
- National Eye Institute, National Institutes of Health [R01-EY028571]
- Office of Behavioral and SocialSciences Research, National Institutes of Health [R01-EY028571]
- NATIONAL EYE INSTITUTE [P30EY001583] Funding Source: NIH RePORTER
Ask authors/readers for more resources
A core goal of visual neuroscience is to predict human perceptual performance from natural signals. Performance in any natural task can be limited by at least three sources of uncertainty: stimulus variability, internal noise, and suboptimal computations. Determining the relative importance of these factors has been a focus of interest for decades but requires methods for predicting the fundamental limits imposed by stimulus variability on sensory-perceptual precision. Most successes have been limited to simple stimuli and simple tasks. But perception science ultimately aims to understand how vision works with natural stimuli. Successes in this domain have proven elusive. Here, we develop a model of humans based on an image-computable (images in, estimates out) Bayesian ideal observer. Given biological constraints, the ideal optimally uses the statistics relating local intensity patterns in moving images to speed, specifying the fundamental limits imposed by natural stimuli. Next, we propose a theoretical link between two key decision-theoretic quantities that suggests how to experimentally disentangle the impacts of internal noise and deterministic suboptimal computations. In several interlocking discrimination experiments with three male observers, we confirm this link and determine the quantitative impact of each candidate performance-limiting factor. Human performance is near-exclusively limited by natural stimulus variability and internal noise, and humans use near-optimal computations to estimate speed from naturalistic image movies. The findings indicate that the partition of behavioral variability can be predicted from a principled analysis of natural images and scenes. The approach should be extendable to studies of neural variability with natural signals.
Authors
I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.
Reviews
Recommended
No Data Available