Nucleobase mutants of a bacterial preQ1-II riboswitch that uncouple metabolite sensing from gene regulation

Riboswitches are a class of nonprotein-coding RNAs that directly sense cellular metabolites to regulate gene expression. They are model systems for analyzing RNA-ligand interactions and are established targets for antibacterial agents. Many studies have analyzed the ligand-binding properties of riboswitches, but this work has outpaced our understanding of the underlying chemical pathways that govern riboswitch-controlled gene expression. To address this knowledge gap, we prepared 15 mutants of the preQ(1)-II riboswitch?a structurally and biochemically well-characterized HLout pseudoknot that recognizes the metabolite prequeuosine(1) (preQ(1)). The mutants span the preQ(1)-binding pocket through the adjoining Shine?Dalgarno sequence (SDS) and include A-minor motifs, pseudoknot-insertion helix P4, U?A-U base triples, and canonical G-C pairs in the anti-SDS. As predicted?and confirmed by in vitro isothermal titration calorimetry measurements?specific mutations ablated preQ(1) binding, but most aberrant binding effects were corrected by compensatory mutations. In contrast, functional analysis in live bacteria using a riboswitch-controlled GFPuv-reporter assay revealed that each mutant had a deleterious effect on gene regulation, even when compensatory changes were included. Our results indicate that effector binding can be uncoupled from gene regulation. We attribute loss of function to defects in a chemical interaction network that links effector binding to distal regions of the fold that support the gene-off RNA conformation. Our findings differentiate effector binding from biological function, which has ramifications for riboswitch characterization. Our results are considered in the context of synthetic ligands and drugs that bind tightly to riboswitches without eliciting a biological response.