A Time-Calibrated Species Tree Phylogeny of the New World Cycad Genus Zamia L. (Zamiaceae, Cycadales)

Premise of research. The genus Zamia L. (Zamiaceae), consisting of 79 species, is the most species-rich and widely distributed cycad genus in the New World and arguably the most morphologically and ecologically diverse genus in the Cycadales. However, a strong phylogenetic framework for this genus is still lacking. Methodology. We used a multilocus sequence data set of 10 independent loci (nine single-copy nuclear genes [SCNGs] and one plastid) and extensive taxon sampling (ca. 90% of species) to infer phylogenetic relationships within Zamia. We implemented a concatenated matrix analysis with maximum parsimony, a partitioned maximum likelihood (ML) analysis, and a time-calibrated Bayesian species tree-estimation approach. Diversification, historical biogeography, and ancestral character state reconstruction analyses were conducted using the species tree topology that was the most morphologically and geographically congruent. Pivotal results. We inferred a robust phylogenetic tree for the genus with a strong geographic delimitation of clades and found that four morphological characters typically used for diagnostic purposes in the genus exhibit a high degree of homoplasy. The stem group of Zamia was estimated to have originated at 68.28 Ma (95% highest posterior density [HPD] 51.0-84.5) and the crown group at 9.54 Ma (95% HPD 9.0-10.62). The majority of species richness in the genus appeared during the Pliocene and Pleistocene, with the highest diversification rates occurring in clades comprising Caribbean and South American species. Biogeographic analysis suggests a Caribbean or Mesoamerican origin for Zamia with subsequent dispersal to the Central American Isthmus and South America, where the genus reaches its maximum species and morphological diversity. Conclusions. The high degree of convergence found in multiple morphological characters has historically confounded efforts to elucidate species relationships using nonphylogenetic methods. This study presents the most species-comprehensive, well-resolved hypothesis of phylogenetic relationships within Zamia and provides a strong phylogenetic framework for further studies.