A Path Integral Molecular Dynamics Study on Intermolecular Hydrogen Bond of Acetic Acid-Arsenic Acid Anion and Acetic Acid-Phosphoric Acid Anion Clusters

We apply ab initio path integral molecular dynamics simulation employing omega B97XD as the quantum chemical calculation method to acetic acid-arsenic acid anion and acetic acid-phosphoric acid anion clusters to investigate the difference of the hydrogen bond structure and its fluctuation such as proton transfer. We found that the nuclear quantum effect enhanced the fluctuation of the hydrogen bond structure and proton transfer, which shows treatment of the nuclear quantum effect was essential to investigate these systems. The hydrogen bond in acetic acid-arsenic acid anion cluster showed characters related to low-barrier hydrogen bonds, while acetic acid-phosphoric acid anion cluster did not. We found non-negligible distinction between these two systems, which could not be found in conventional calculations. We suggest that the difference in amount of atomic charge of the atoms consisting the hydrogen bond is the origin of the difference between acetic acid-arsenic acid and acetic acid-phosphoric acid anion cluster. (C) 2018 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.