Nucleotide based covalent inhibitors of KRas can only be efficient in vivo if they bind reversibly with GTP-like affinity

Simple reversible competitive inhibition of nucleotide binding of GTP to Ras family GTPases has long been recognized as an unlikely approach to manipulating the activity of such proteins for experimental or therapeutic purposes. This is due to the high affinity of GTP to GTPases coupled with high cellular GTP concentrations, but also to problems of specificity for the highly conserved binding sites in GTPases. A recent approach suggested that these problems might be overcome by using GDP derivatives that can undergo a covalent reaction with disease specific mutants, in particular addressing inhibition of KRas(G12C) using GDP equipped with an electrophilic group at the beta-phosphate. We show here that a major drawback to this approach is a loss of reversible affinity of such beta-modified derivatives for Ras of at least 10(4) compared to GTP and GDP. With the help of a thorough kinetic characterization, we show that this leads to covalent reaction times that are too slow to make the compounds attractive for intracellular use, but that generation of a hypothetical reactive GDP derivative that retains the high reversible affinity of GDP/GTP to Ras might be a viable alternative.