How to measure hazards/risks following exposures to nanoscale or pigment-grade titanium dioxide particles

Due to its multifunctional applications, titanium dioxide particles have widespread use in commerce. The particle-types function as sources of pigment color, in food products, anti-bacterial components, ultraviolet radiation scavengers, catalysts, as well as in cosmetics. Because of its inherent properties in a diverse number of products, exposures may occur via any of the major point-of-entry routes, i.e., inhalation, oral or dermal. Although the majority of TiO2 applications are known to exist in the pigment-grade form, nanoscale forms of TiO2 are also common components in several products. This brief review is designed to identify relevant toxicology and risk-related issues which inform health effects assessments on the various forms of titanium dioxide particles. While there has been an abundance of hazard data generated on titanium dioxide particulates, many of the published reports have limited informational value for assessing health effects due, in large part, to shortcomings in experimental design issues, such as: (1) inadequate material characterization of test samples; (2) questionable relevance of experimental systems employed to simulate human exposures; (3) applications of generally high doses, exclusive focus on acute toxicity endpoints, and a lack of reference benchmark control materials, to afford interpretation of measured results; and/or (4) failure to recognize fundamental differences between hazard and risk concepts. Accordingly, a number of important toxicology issues are identified and integrated herein to provide a more comprehensive assessment of the health risks of different forms of pigment-grade and nanoscale titanium dioxide particles. It is important to note that particle-types of different TiO2 compositions may have variable toxicity potencies, depending upon crystal structure, particle size, particle surface characteristics and surface coatings. In order to develop a more robust health risk evaluation of TiO2 particle exposures, this review focuses on the following issues: (1) Introduction to TiO2 particle chemistry/functionality and importance of robust material characterization of test samples; (2) Implementation of meaningful hazard studies for gauging EHS safety issues - pulmonary bioassay data and development of the Nano Risk Framework for developmental nano TiO2 compounds; (3) Epidemiological study findings on titanium dioxide workers - the most heavily-exposed populations; (4) Methodologies for setting occupational exposure limits including benchmarking or bridging comparisons; and (5) The importance of particle overload data in the lungs of rats as it relates to gauging the relevance of health effects for humans. A comprehensive evaluation of the existing animal and human health data is a necessary prerequisite for facilitating accurate assessments of human health risks to TiO2 exposures. (C) 2013 Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.