Journal
STATISTICAL SCIENCE
Volume 24, Issue 4, Pages 414-429Publisher
INST MATHEMATICAL STATISTICS
DOI: 10.1214/09-STS288
Keywords
Multistage sampling; genetic associations; replication; resequencing; DNA pooling; gene-environment interactions
Categories
Funding
- NIH [5U01 ES015090]
Ask authors/readers for more resources
Because of the high cost of commercial genotyping chip technologies, many investigations have used a two-stage design for genome-wide association studies, using part of the sample for an initial discovery of promising SNPs at a less stringent significance level and the remainder in a joint analysis of just these SNPs using custom genotyping. Typical cost savings of about 50% are possible with this design to obtain comparable levels of overall type I error and power by using about half the sample for stage I and carrying about 0.1% of SNPs forward to the second stage, the optimal design depending primarily upon the ratio of costs per genotype for stages I and II. However, with the rapidly declining costs of the commercial panels, the generally low observed ORs of current studies, and many studies aiming to test multiple hypotheses and multiple endpoints, many investigators are abandoning the two-stage design in favor of simply genotyping all available subjects using a standard high-density panel. Concern is sometimes raised about the absence of a replication panel in this approach, as required by some high-profile journals, but it must be appreciated that the two-stage design is not a discovery/replication design but simply a more efficient design for discovery using, a joint analysis of the data from both stages. Once a subset of highly-significant associations has been discovered, a truly independent exact replication study is needed in a similar population of the same promising SNPs using similar methods. This can then be followed by (1) generalizability studies to assess the full scope of replicated associations across different races, different endpoints, different interactions, etc.; (2) fine-mapping or resequencing to try to identify the causal variant; and (3) experimental studies of the biological function of these genes. Multistage sampling designs may be more useful at this stage, say, for selecting subsets of subjects for deep resequencing of regions identified in the GWAS.
Authors
I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.
Reviews
Recommended
No Data Available